Building relationships, one coin at a time.
At Cherokee Coins & Jewelry, Inc., we are a family-owned and operated coin dealer that has been serving Louisville, KY, and the surrounding areas for over 40 years. Our business is built on honesty, integrity, and a passion for coin collecting and jewelry. We pride ourselves on paying fair prices for the items we purchase, and we always strive to provide exceptional customer service.
Our Story
Our owner, Steve Kommor, was inspired to start his own coin shop after discovering a bag of Buffalo Head Nickels and Indian Head Cents in his backyard as a seven-year-old boy. This sparked a lifelong love of coin collecting, and by the time Steve went to college, he was buying and selling coins at regional coin shows. In 1980, he opened the doors to Cherokee Coins and Jewelry, and the rest is history. Steve's business partner and wife, Susan, serves as COO, overseeing the website, marketing, and communications. Together, they have built a national reputation as trusted coin dealers.
Services
We offer a wide range of services, including buying and selling coins, jewelry, and collectibles. Our large showroom features key date coins, type coins, silver and gold coins, dollar collections, paper money, and other collectible memorabilia. We also sell rare jewelry, including diamonds, antiques, and more. Additionally, we provide expert appraisals and valuations for collections and individuals. Whether you're looking to purchase a special gift or sell your assets, we're here to help.
Why Choose Us
At Cherokee Coins & Jewelry, we're committed to providing exceptional customer service and building long-term relationships with our customers. We're proud of our reputation for honesty, integrity, and fair prices. We're also proud members of the American Numismatic Association (ANA), CoinNet, and authorized dealers for Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS) and Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC).
Get in Touch
We invite you to visit our showroom, located at 1825 Bardstown Road, Louisville, KY 40205. You can also contact us by phone at 502-458-6787 or email us at susan@cherokeecoinsandjewelry.com. We look forward to serving you!
Overall Experience
Reviews of Cherokee Coins & Jewelry are largely positive, with customers praising the store's helpful and knowledgeable staff, fair pricing, and wide selection of coins and jewelry.
Positive Aspects
- Many reviewers praised Steve, the owner, for his expertise, friendly demeanor, and willingness to help customers find what they're looking for.
- The store is commended for its competitive pricing, with several reviewers stating that they received fair prices for their coins and jewelry.
- Customers appreciate the store's extensive inventory, with many finding exactly what they were looking for.
Negative Aspects
- A few reviewers had negative experiences, citing rude or pushy sales tactics, lowball offers, and a lack of attention from the staff.
- Some customers felt that they were not taken seriously or were not given a fair deal due to their age, race, or perceived lack of knowledge.
Common Themes
- Many reviewers appreciated the store's honesty and transparency, with several stating that they felt comfortable and confident in their transactions.
- Customers often mentioned the store's expertise and knowledge of coins and jewelry, with several praising Steve's ability to find specific items or provide valuable advice.

Be the first to review Cherokee Coins & Jewelry.
Write a Review