Business Details
13 Years
experience
Authentic Italian Pizza & Cuisine in Bethpage, NY
Villa Maria Pizza has been Bethpage's premier destination for authentic Italian cuisine since 2013. Founded by Chef Michael Goldsborough, a Culinary Institute of America graduate with decades of experience as a former NYC Executive Chef, we specialize in handcrafted Italian dishes made from scratch using the freshest ingredients. Our menu features award-winning pizzas, house-made pastas, and catering services for events of all sizes, serving Bethpage, Levittown, and surrounding Long Island communities.With a commitment to quality and customer satisfaction, our team ensures every dining experience - whether in-house, takeout, or catering - reflects our passion for Italian culinary traditions. Located conveniently near Hempstead Turnpike, we pride ourselves on providing exceptional food and service that keeps customers returning week after week.
Services
Pizza
Pasta
Catering
Meatball Heroes
Garlic Knots
Baked Specialties
Lunch Specials
Dinner Combos
Details
- Year established: 2013
Highlights and features
- We offer decades of culinary expertise from a CIA-graduate executive chef
- Our dishes are made from scratch using only the freshest ingredients
- We provide full-service catering for events from 10 to 1,000 guests
- We serve Bethpage's best-rated pizza and meatball heroes weekly
- Our convenient Long Island location serves multiple surrounding communities
What people say
Best pizza around
Flawless service
Outstanding food
Perfect catering
Fresh ingredients
Services
Pizza
Our signature pizzas feature hand-tossed dough topped with premium ingredients. Available in classic cheese or specialty combinations, each pizza is baked to perfection in our traditional brick oven. Perfect for individual meals or sharing with family and friends.
Catering
Full-service catering for weddings, corporate events, and private parties. We offer customizable menus featuring our popular Italian dishes, with options to serve groups from 10 to 1,000 guests. Professional service includes setup and cleanup.
Pasta
House-made pasta dishes prepared daily using traditional Italian recipes. Choose from classic options like spaghetti and meatballs or specialty items like penne alla vodka and baked ziti. Served with garlic bread and salad.
Meatball Heroes
Gourmet hero sandwiches featuring our award-winning meatballs. Available with chicken, eggplant, or sausage parmesan options. Served on fresh-baked rolls with house-made marinara and mozzarella cheese. Perfect for quick lunches or casual meals.
Family Specials
Value-priced meal combinations designed for family dining. Includes large pizzas, baked specialties, garlic knots, and salads. Weekly specials offer great savings while providing generous portions that feed multiple people with authentic Italian flavors.
People
Michael Goldsborough
Owner & Executive Chef
Culinary Institute of America graduate with decades of experience as a NYC Executive Chef. Brings professional expertise to Villa Maria Pizza's menu development and daily kitchen operations while maintaining hands-on customer service.
Questions
What are your most popular menu items?
Our award-winning cheese pizza, house-made meatball heroes, and baked ziti are customer favorites. Weekly specials include family-style combinations and gourmet pasta dishes.
Do you offer catering services?
Yes, we provide full-service catering for events of all sizes with customizable menus featuring our popular Italian dishes and professional service staff.
What are your operating hours?
We're open Monday-Thursday 11:30am-8:30pm, Friday-Saturday 11:30am-9pm, and Sunday 12pm-8pm for dine-in, takeout, and catering orders.
Where are you located?
We're conveniently located at 376 N Wantagh Ave, Bethpage, NY 11714, just half a mile from the Hempstead Turnpike intersection.
Do you accept credit cards?
We accept all major credit cards for in-restaurant dining and catering services. Payment options are also available for online ordering.
What makes your restaurant unique?
Our CIA-graduate chef combines traditional Italian recipes with premium ingredients, while our catering services and weekly specials provide exceptional value for Long Island diners.
