At All Star Pizza, we are passionate about serving the community with the finest New York-style pizza, made with love and care. Our story began in 2000, when we opened our doors with a commitment to providing outstanding food and customer service. We knew that we had to bring our A-game to establish ourselves in the Penfield area, known for its rich pizza culture.
Our Recipe for Success
To stand out from the competition, we focused on creating a signature pizza that would set us apart. Our chefs perfected the art of making the perfect sauce, garlic, and dough. We traveled to the Bronx to learn the secrets of traditional New York-style pizza and incorporated those techniques into our own dough-making process. The result is a unique crust that is thin yet crispy, with just the right balance of crunch and chew.
Our Commitment to Quality
Our commitment to quality doesn't stop at our crust. We source our vegetables from local farms when in season to ensure freshness and flavor. Our meats are always of high quality, and our cheeses are carefully selected to melt to perfection. We also take pride in our commitment to customer service, striving to go above and beyond to satisfy our customers' cravings.
Catering and Events
Whether it's a small gathering or a large event, we're here to help. We offer a variety of catering options, from subs and salads to sheet pizzas and more. We're happy to work with you to create a customized menu that fits your needs and budget. Our team is dedicated to ensuring that your event is a success.
Serving the Community
As a locally owned and operated business, we're proud to be part of the Penfield community. We're committed to supporting local organizations and events, and we're proud to be a trusted favorite among the community.
Our Menu
From classic pizzas to innovative specialty pizzas and sandwiches, our menu has something for everyone. Whether you're in the mood for a traditional margherita pizza or a more adventurous combination, we've got you covered. We also offer gluten-free and vegan options to accommodate dietary restrictions.
Contact Us
We're always here to help. Call us today to place an order, ask a question, or simply to show your support for our local business.
Overall Experience
The reviews are mixed, with some customers having a positive experience and others having a negative one.
Food Quality
Positive Comments
Some customers raved about the pizza, mentioning that it's the best in the area, with delicious flavor and plenty of veggies to choose from. The thin crust was a hit, with some saying it's the perfect balance between crispy and soggy. Vegan options were also appreciated, including vegan cheese and pepperoni. Wings were also praised, with crispy exterior and juicy interior.
Negative Comments
On the other hand, some customers were disappointed with the food quality, citing issues with chewy or burnt crust, minimal flavor, and poor quality wings. One customer mentioned that the wings were made with old oil and had wrong toppings.
Service and Atmosphere
Positive Comments
Many customers praised the service, mentioning that it's friendly and efficient. Some appreciated the option for delivery or pickup, and the fast turnaround time. The atmosphere was described as casual and cozy, with some saying it's a great spot for a quick bite.
Negative Comments
A few customers mentioned that the seating area is small, and one customer was unhappy with the service, citing that the owner and manager need to step up their game.
Conclusion
While some customers had a great experience with All-Star Pizza, others were disappointed with the food quality and service. However, the majority of the reviews are positive, highlighting the pizza joint's strengths in terms of flavor, options, and service.
Be the first to review All Star Pizza.
Write a Review
