Business Details
26 Years
experience
Your Go-To Pizza Spot in Penfield, NY
Since opening our doors in 2000, All Star Pizza has been dedicated to delivering exceptional pizza and catering services to the Penfield community. Our commitment begins with fresh, locally sourced ingredients when in season, including hand-peeled garlic and house-made sauces that define our signature flavors. We specialize in New York-style brick oven pizza with three crust optionsthin, regular, and thickto accommodate every preference. Our team travels to the Bronx to perfect our dough-making techniques, ensuring a unique crust that has earned us recognition as the best pizza in Penfield.Beyond pizza, we offer catering for events of 10 or more guests, with diverse menu options including subs, salads, and sheet pizzas. As a women-owned small business, we prioritize personalized service and community involvement, supporting local organizations without political affiliations. Our dedication to quality extends to delivery seven days a week and accommodating dietary needs with gluten-free and vegan cheese options.
Services
Pizza Delivery
Catering Services
Gluten-Free Pizza
Vegan Cheese Options
Sub Trays
Details
- Year established: 2000
Highlights and features
- We use fresh, locally sourced vegetables and house-made sauces for authentic flavors.
- Our catering services accommodate events from 10 to 100+ guests with diverse menus.
- Three crust options ensure every guest enjoys their perfect pizza style.
- Award-winning recognition for best pizza, sauce, and crust in Penfield.
- Women-owned small business committed to community and personalized service.
What people say
Best pizza in Penfield
Fresh ingredients
Great catering options
Excellent customer service
Delicious house-made sauces
Services
Pizza Delivery
Enjoy fresh, handcrafted pizzas delivered directly to your home or office in Penfield, East Rochester, and Browncroft. Choose from New York-style, regular, or thick crusts with over 20 toppings. Our delivery service operates seven days a week, ensuring hot, timely meals for every occasion.
Catering Services
Elevate your next event with All Star Pizza's catering, serving parties of 10 or more. Options include sub trays, sheet pizzas, salads, and baked ziti. Our team works closely with clients to customize menus, offering delivery and setup for weddings, corporate events, and community gatherings in the Penfield area.
Gluten-Free Pizza
All Star Pizza accommodates dietary needs with gluten-free pizza options. Our 10-inch gluten-free crust is topped with house-made sauces and fresh ingredients, including locally sourced vegetables. This service ensures guests with dietary restrictions can enjoy our award-winning flavors without compromising quality or taste.
Sub Trays
Order freshly baked sub trays for large groups, featuring turkey, ham, roast beef, or tuna on 12-inch rolls. Customize with toppings like lettuce, peppers, and cheeses. Available in 4-sub (10-12 servings) or 6-sub (14-16 servings) trays, ideal for office lunches, sports teams, or family gatherings.
Specialty Pizzas
Indulge in our chef-crafted specialty pizzas, including Meat Lovers, Veggie, and Chicken Wing varieties. Each features house-made sauces, premium toppings, and three crust options. These pizzas highlight our commitment to quality, with ingredients like fresh spinach, artichoke hearts, and hand-peeled garlic for a distinctive, award-winning flavor profile.
Questions
What makes All Star Pizza's crust unique?
Our New York-style crust is crafted using a recipe refined through research in the Bronx, offering a thin yet sturdy base with a distinct flavor from our house-made dough.
Do you offer catering for large events?
Yes, we cater events with 10+ guests, providing sub trays, sheet pizzas, salads, and customized options. Call us at least 24 hours in advance to plan your order.
Are there dietary-friendly options available?
We offer gluten-free pizza crusts and vegan cheese to accommodate dietary restrictions while maintaining the quality and taste our customers expect.
What areas do you deliver to?
We deliver to Penfield, East Rochester, and Browncroft, NY, seven days a week during our operating hours.
How can I place a catering order?
Call us at (585) 385-2244 at least 24 hours in advance, and our team will help customize your menu and arrange delivery or pickup.
What are your current operating hours?
We're open Monday-Thursday 11 AM–10 PM, Friday-Saturday 11 AM–11 PM, and Sunday 11 AM–10 PM.
