Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
16 Years
experience
Artisan Breads, Pastries & Key Lime Pie in Key West
Old Town Bakery, established in May 2010, is nestled in a historic 19th-century building at the corner of Eaton and Grinnell Streets in Key West's Old Town. Our commitment to traditional, handmade baking methods is reflected in every loaf of bread, pastry, and sandwich we create. The renovation of this once-vacant landmark preserved its Dade County pine walls and exposed beams, blending Old World charm with modern hospitality. Locals and tourists alike gather daily for our oven-fresh breads, breakfast and lunch sandwiches, and award-winning Key Lime Pie. We pride ourselves on serving freshly ground coffee, including espresso, latte, and cappuccino, alongside an array of hot and cold beverages.

Our reputation as a neighborhood mainstay grew through dedication to quality and community connection. The bakery's popularity extends beyond Key West, with visitors seeking our signature desserts and party platters. Recognized as having the Best Key Lime Pies in the Florida Keys by Miami NewTimes, we continue to honor tradition while innovating our offerings. Every item is crafted with care, from classic croissants to seasonal specialties, ensuring a memorable experience with every visit. Our online ordering system provides convenient access to our full menu for pickup or delivery, making our artisanal treats available to more customers.
Services
Artisan Breads Pastries Breakfast Sandwiches Key Lime Pie Online Ordering
Details
  • Year established: 2010
Highlights and features
  • Voted Best Key Lime Pies in the Florida Keys by Miami NewTimes
  • Handmade baked goods using traditional, old-world methods
  • Historic 19th-century building with authentic Key West charm
  • Locals' favorite for daily fresh breads and community atmosphere
  • Online ordering available for convenient pickup or delivery
What people say
Best Key Lime Pie Freshly baked daily Cozy historic ambiance Popular with locals Great coffee selection
Services
Artisan Breads
Our bakery crafts traditional artisan breads using time-honored techniques. Each loaf is baked fresh daily from scratch, featuring classic baguettes, sourdoughs, and specialty breads made with high-quality ingredients. The process combines old-world methods with modern quality standards to ensure perfect texture and flavor.
Pastries
We offer a wide selection of handcrafted pastries made from scratch daily. Our menu includes classic croissants, Danish specialties, scones, and seasonal fruit tarts. Each pastry combines flaky layers and premium ingredients, following traditional recipes that highlight our bakers' expertise in European-style pastry making.
Breakfast Sandwiches
Custom-made breakfast sandwiches feature eggs, meats, and cheeses on freshly baked breads. We use oven-warmed buns and locally sourced ingredients to create hearty morning meals. The menu balances traditional favorites with creative combinations, all prepared to order for optimal freshness and taste.
Key Lime Pie
Our award-winning Key Lime Pie features a graham cracker crust filled with tangy lime custard and whipped topping. Made with authentic Key limes and premium ingredients, this dessert earned recognition as the best in the Florida Keys. The recipe preserves traditional flavors while maintaining consistent quality across every slice.
Online Ordering
Convenient online ordering allows customers to schedule pickup or delivery of our baked goods. The system supports advance orders for specialty items and party platters. This digital solution maintains our quality standards while expanding access to our products for both residents and visitors.
Questions
What makes your Key Lime Pie the best in the Florida Keys?
Our Key Lime Pie uses authentic Key limes and a secret family recipe that won Miami NewTimes' Best Key Lime Pie award. We maintain consistent quality through precise preparation methods and premium ingredients.
Do you offer custom party platters?
Yes, we create custom party platters with baked goods, pastries, and sandwiches. Orders require advance notice to ensure proper preparation and presentation for your event.
Are you located in Old Town Key West?
Yes, we're at the corner of Eaton and Grinnell Streets in Key West's Old Town district, five blocks east of Duval Street in a historic 19th-century building.
What coffee options do you serve?
We offer freshly ground coffee including espresso, latte, cappuccino, and regular brew. Both hot and cold options are available, along with specialty drinks and tea selections.
Do you have online ordering for pickup or delivery?
Yes, our online ordering system allows advance orders for pickup or delivery. This service provides convenient access to our full menu of baked goods and prepared foods.
What are your most popular baked goods?
Besides our award-winning Key Lime Pie, popular items include classic croissants, baguettes, breakfast sandwiches on fresh bread, and seasonal pastries like peach cobbler danish and raspberry scones.