Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
25 Years
experience
Award-Winning Custom Cakes in Key West
Since 2001, Key West Cakes has been dedicated to crafting exceptional cakes that combine artistic presentation with unparalleled flavor. Founded by Paulie and Steven in a home kitchen, our bakery has grown into a beloved local institution while maintaining the same passion for quality and creativity. Our team of skilled cake artists operates from our custom bakery on historic White Street, where we handcraft every creation on-site to ensure freshness and excellence. Recognized by The Knot as a top wedding vendor, we specialize in custom wedding cakes, birthday celebrations, and specialty desserts for events of all sizes.

We prioritize personalized service, offering complimentary tastings and flexible customization options to match your vision. From color-matched designs to unique flavor combinations, our commitment to detail has made us a trusted name in Key West. We invite you to experience our creations firsthand at our retail location, where daily delights are always available for pickup. With over two decades of experience, we continue to innovate while staying true to our founding principles of quality, creativity, and customer satisfaction.
Services
Wedding Cakes Birthday Cakes Specialty Cakes Cake Tastings Custom Cake Toppers
Details
  • Year established: 2001
Highlights and features
  • 20+ years of experience in custom cake design
  • Awarded 'Best in Weddings' by The Knot
  • Complimentary tasting sessions for event planning
  • Custom non-edible cake topper creation
  • Color-matching service for event coordination
Associations and certifications
  • The Knot 'Best in Weddings'
What people say
Award-winning Exquisite custom cakes Delicious flavors Exceptional service Creative designs
Services
Wedding Cakes
Custom-designed wedding cakes tailored to your ceremony's theme and color scheme. Our expert bakers create multi-tiered masterpieces using premium ingredients, with options for gluten-free and vegan adaptations. Each design includes complimentary consultations and tasting sessions to ensure perfection for your special day.
Birthday Cakes
Unique birthday cakes for all ages featuring handcrafted decorations and signature flavor combinations. From whimsical themes to elegant designs, our team works closely with clients to create memorable centerpieces that match party aesthetics and dietary preferences.
Specialty Cakes
Artistic specialty cakes for anniversaries, corporate events, and unique celebrations. Our bakery offers innovative flavor profiles and structural designs, including sculpted cakes and interactive dessert displays. Available for pickup or delivery within the Florida Keys region.
Cake Tastings
Complimentary tasting sessions featuring our signature cake flavors and fillings. Available by appointment Monday-Friday, these 30-minute consultations allow couples to sample up to three flavor combinations while discussing design options with our expert cake designers.
Custom Toppers
Handmade custom cake toppers using edible and non-edible materials. Our designers create personalized elements like monogrammed signs, beach-themed accents, and themed figurines to perfectly complement your cake's design and event motif.
Questions
Do you offer cake tastings?
Yes, we provide one complimentary tasting serving 2-3 people by appointment Monday-Friday 12pm-5:30pm.
What wedding cake services do you provide?
We create custom wedding cakes with 50% deposit required for booking, offering design consultations and multiple flavor options.
Can you match specific cake colors?
We match colors using provided swatches but cannot guarantee exact replication of any specific shade.
Do you make custom cake toppers?
Yes, we create custom non-edible toppers including themed designs, monograms, and event-specific decorations.
What cake flavors are available?
We offer 16 specialty flavors including Key Lime, Hummingbird, Carrot, and Red Velvet with various filling options.