Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
33 Years
experience
Your Trusted One-Stop Shop on Keuka Lake
Since 1993, Crooked Lake Mercantile has been a cornerstone of the Branchport community, nestled in a historic 1890s country store on Keuka Lake's northwest branch. Our mission is to provide locals and visitors with a diverse array of groceries, homemade deli items, and unique Keuka Lake-themed merchandise. We pride ourselves on blending the charm of yesteryear with modern convenience, offering everything from daily essentials to antiques and souvenirs. Our deli and bakery serve fresh, handcrafted goods in a welcoming atmosphere, perfect for enjoying on-site or taking to-go. As a hub for the Finger Lakes region, we curate products from eight independent dealers through our Antiques and Oddities Co-op.

Over three decades, weve built a reputation for exceptional customer service and a commitment to meeting every need, whether youre a seasonal visitor or a lifelong resident. Our wooden shelves and cozy ambiance reflect our dedication to preserving local heritage while adapting to contemporary demands. From picnic essentials to one-of-a-kind gifts, we strive to be your trusted companion for all things Keuka. Our team remains passionate about fostering community connections and ensuring every shopping experience is memorable and satisfying.
Services
Grocery Store Deli/Bakery Keuka Lake Merchandise Antiques Co-op Retail
Details
  • Year established: 1993
Highlights and features
  • We offer over 30 years of experience serving the Finger Lakes community.
  • Our historic 1890s store blends charm with modern convenience.
  • We provide a curated selection of groceries, deli items, and local souvenirs.
  • Our Antiques and Oddities Co-op features unique finds from eight dealers.
  • We guarantee a warm, personalized shopping experience for every customer.
Services
Grocery Store
Our grocery department stocks a full line of home staples and daily essentials on historic wooden shelves. We specialize in locally sourced products and hard-to-find items. Whether you need pantry basics or specialty goods, our shelves offer a nostalgic yet practical shopping experience for residents and visitors alike.
Deli/Bakery
The deli and bakery feature homemade sandwiches, fresh-baked breads, and seasonal specialties. Customers enjoy made-to-order meals in our cozy dining area or packed for picnics. Our menu includes classic combinations and unique creations using locally inspired ingredients, all prepared in a warm, welcoming environment.
Keuka Lake Merchandise
We offer the largest selection of Keuka Lake-themed apparel, gifts, and souvenirs in the region. From t-shirts and hoodies to handcrafted decor and novelty items, our merchandise celebrates local culture and provides perfect mementos for visitors and residents alike.
Antiques
Our Antiques and Oddities Co-op showcases curated items from eight independent dealers across 2,000 square feet. Shoppers discover unique vintage pieces, collectibles, and rare finds in a collaborative space that preserves regional history and craftsmanship.
Co-op Retail
The co-op model supports local artisans and dealers by providing shared retail space. This collaborative approach offers customers diverse product selections while fostering community economic growth through small business partnerships.
Questions
What are Crooked Lake Mercantile's business hours?
We are open Monday through Saturday from 8:00 AM to 4:00 PM, and Sundays from 8:00 AM to 1:00 PM.
Do you carry Keuka Lake-specific souvenirs?
Yes, we offer the largest selection of Keuka Lake-themed apparel, gifts, and souvenirs in the region, including exclusive local designs.
Is the store located near Keuka Lake attractions?
We're conveniently situated at the four corners of Branchport on Keuka Lake's northwest branch, easily accessible from major regional attractions.
Do you have grocery delivery services?
Currently, we focus on in-store shopping experiences but offer assistance with special orders for local customers needing specific items.
Are there dining options at the Mercantile?
Our deli provides eat-in and takeout options with homemade sandwiches, fresh-baked breads, and seasonal specialties in a cozy atmosphere.
Do you accept credit cards?
Payment method details aren't specified in our materials, but we recommend contacting us directly at (315) 595-2233 for current payment options.