Business Details
Award-Winning Steaks & Fine Dining in Appleton, WI
George's Steak House has been a cornerstone of Appleton's dining scene since the late 1930s, offering an authentic steakhouse experience rooted in tradition. Founded by George Fiedler, our establishment has passed through generations of dedicated owners, each preserving the legacy of quality food and warm hospitality. Our current owners, the Quimby family, continue this heritage with over four decades of hands-on operation, ensuring every cut of meat and dish meets exacting standards. The iconic 125-year-old Steinway piano adds to our unique ambiance, creating memorable evenings with live entertainment. We specialize in premium steaks, prime rib, and seafood, complemented by classic cocktails and an extensive wine list. Our Friday Fish Fry with 10 specialty options remains a local favorite, while private dining spaces accommodate events from intimate gatherings to celebrations of up to 55 guests.Recognized as the Best Steak in the Valley by Fox Cities Magazine for over a decade, we maintain our commitment to excellence through skilled chefs and attentive service. The Quimby family and staff personally oversee daily operations, ensuring each visit reflects our dedication to quality and customer satisfaction. Our history as a Fox Valley institution is matched only by our focus on delivering consistent, exceptional dining experiences. Whether for business meetings, special occasions, or casual meals, George's provides a timeless setting where guests can enjoy superior food and genuine hospitality.
Services
Steakhouse Dining
Piano Bar Entertainment
Private Event Hosting
Gift Certificates
Friday Fish Fry
Highlights and features
- 70+ years serving Appleton with steakhouse excellence
- 10-time Fox Cities Magazine Golden Fork Award winner for Best Steak
- Hosts private events from 15-55 guests with dedicated spaces
- Features Wisconsin's only 125-year-old Steinway piano bar
- Family-owned operation maintaining generational culinary standards
What people say
Award-winning steaks
Historic atmosphere
Attentive service
Memorable events
Talented musicians
Services
Steakhouse Dining
Our steakhouse offers USDA Choice cuts aged to perfection, featuring 16oz and 22oz prime rib options. Expert chefs prepare each dish to order, complemented by fresh seafood, poultry, and house-made desserts. The menu maintains traditional steakhouse elements while incorporating modern culinary techniques.
Piano Bar Entertainment
The Steinway concert grand piano provides nightly entertainment with performances spanning Sinatra to contemporary hits. Talented musicians create an energetic atmosphere Friday and Saturday nights, enhancing the dining experience with interactive musical performances in our lounge area.
Private Event Hosting
Three dedicated event spaces accommodate gatherings from 15 to 55 guests, including the historic Barrel Room. Custom menus and inclusive packages available for weddings, anniversaries, and corporate events. Preferred dining partner for Fox Cities Performing Arts Center patrons.
Friday Fish Fry
Weekly fish fry features 10 specialty preparations including Boston Clam Chowder and traditional Wisconsin-style fish. Fresh seafood selections prepared daily, offering both casual lunch options and premium dinner portions in a festive Friday atmosphere.
Gift Certificates
Custom denomination gift certificates available for purchase in-person or by phone. Recipient mailing options provided for direct delivery. Ideal for special occasions, corporate gifts, or as flexible dining options for Appleton visitors.
People
Chuck Quimby
Co-Owner
Co-owner with Edie Quimby since 1976, bringing construction and hospitality expertise. Former home builder who mastered meat cutting and bartending. Maintains operational oversight while preserving the establishment's historic character.
Edie Quimby
Co-Owner
Began career as waitress in 1967, progressed to bookkeeping and management. Co-owner since 1976, ensuring financial integrity while maintaining family business traditions. Oversees daily operations with hands-on approach.
Brad Quimby
Operator
Third-generation operator who joined full-time after graduating St. Norbert College in 1985. Managed dishwashing to kitchen operations during youth. Maintains quality standards while balancing tradition with modern dining expectations.
Questions
What makes George's Steak House unique?
Our 125-year-old Steinway piano provides live entertainment, while our 70-year tradition of dry-aging prime rib and hand-cut steaks maintains historic quality standards.
Do you offer private dining options?
Three private spaces accommodate groups from 15-55 guests, including the historic Barrel Room. Custom menus and event planning assistance available for special occasions.
What are your signature dishes?
16oz and 22oz prime rib cuts, 10 specialty Friday Fish Fry options, and house-made desserts complement our USDA Choice steaks aged to perfection.
How can I make reservations?
Reservations require advance telephone booking at (920) 733-4939. Strongly recommended for all visits, with walk-ins accommodated when possible.
What entertainment options exist?
Live piano performances Friday and Saturday nights feature talented musicians playing diverse repertoires on our historic Steinway concert grand piano.
Are gift certificates available?
Custom denomination gift certificates can be purchased in-person or by phone, with direct mailing options available for recipients.
