Celebrating 50 Years of Excellence, One Piece at a Time.
At Payne Anthony Creative Jewelers, we're proud to celebrate our 50th Anniversary, marking five decades of excellence in the world of fine jewelry. As we embark on a new decade, we're excited to announce our transition to focusing exclusively on Custom Design and Special Orders. This new direction allows us to continue providing our esteemed customers with the same exceptional service and unparalleled expertise that has made us the go-to destination for jewelry enthusiasts in Salt Lake City, UT.
Our Story
Established in 1974, Payne Anthony Creative Jewelers has built a reputation for delivering outstanding quality, unbeatable customer service, and a commitment to craftsmanship that sets us apart from the rest. Our experienced team of experts, led by Steve, Jeff, Jennifer, Meri, and Chris, are dedicated to providing personalized consultations, bespoke designs, and meticulous attention to detail that ensures every piece of jewelry that leaves our workshop is truly unique and exceptional.
Services
At Payne Anthony Creative Jewelers, we offer an extensive range of services designed to cater to the diverse needs of our discerning clients. From custom design and special orders to diamond search and jewelry repair, our team of skilled professionals is dedicated to delivering exceptional results that exceed your expectations.
- Custom Design: Our team of experienced designers will work closely with you to bring your vision to life, crafting bespoke pieces that reflect your unique style and personality.
- Special Orders: Whether you're looking for a one-of-a-kind piece or a custom variation of an existing design, our expert jewelers will work tirelessly to bring your dreams to reality.
- Diamond Search: Explore our extensive collection of certified diamonds, carefully selected for their exceptional quality and brilliance.
- Jewelry Repair: Trust our skilled craftsmen to restore your treasured pieces to their former glory, using only the finest materials and techniques.
Our Team
Our team of experts is comprised of passionate individuals who share a deep love for fine jewelry and a commitment to delivering exceptional customer service. With years of combined experience, our team is dedicated to providing personalized consultations, expert advice, and meticulous attention to detail that ensures every customer leaves our store feeling valued and satisfied.
Education & History
At Payne Anthony Creative Jewelers, we believe that education is key to making informed decisions when it comes to fine jewelry. Our team is committed to providing our customers with the knowledge and expertise necessary to make confident purchasing decisions. From diamond grading to jewelry care, we're dedicated to empowering our customers with the information they need to appreciate and enjoy their jewelry for generations to come.
Testimonials
Don't just take our word for it! Our customers rave about their experiences with Payne Anthony Creative Jewelers. Here's what some of our satisfied clients have to say:
- "The best jeweler in Salt Lake for over 30 years - can't be matched for quality, integrity, gorgeous awesome original pieces, and caring, personal service. LOVE THEM! Ten Stars!" - Marshall C.
Overall Experience
Payne Anthony Creative Jewelers has received mixed reviews from customers. While many reviewers had positive experiences, one reviewer had a very poor experience that highlighted issues with customer service, communication, and quality of products.
Positive Experiences
Many reviewers praised the friendly and knowledgeable staff, particularly Jennifer, Steve, and Jeff, who provided excellent customer service, made customizations, and offered expert advice. Some reviewers appreciated the unique and extensive selection of jewelry, competitive pricing, and the ability to find one-of-a-kind pieces. Others appreciated the personalized service, flexibility, and attention to detail provided by the staff.
Negative Experience
One reviewer had a very poor experience, citing rudeness from an employee, poor communication, and a lack of attention to detail. The reviewer felt judged based on their appearance and was disappointed with the quality of the product, which did not meet their expectations.
Common Themes
- Excellent customer service from specific staff members (Jennifer, Steve, and Jeff)
- Unique and extensive selection of jewelry
- Competitive pricing
- Personalized service and attention to detail
- Poor communication and rudeness from one employee (Meri)

Be the first to review Payne Anthony Creative Jewelers.
Write a Review