Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Bakery for Fresh Pastries & Custom Cakes in Centereach, NY
For over a century, Benkerts has been dedicated to delivering excellence through our baked goods, combining four generations of family tradition with a commitment to quality. Our bakery prides itself on using only the finest ingredients to create fresh pastries, custom cakes, and artisan breads that meet the highest standards of taste and craftsmanship. With decades of experience serving Long Island, we maintain a steadfast focus on customer satisfaction through reliable service and products that reflect our heritage of excellence.Our team approaches every order with the same passion and attention to detail that defined our founders' vision, ensuring each customer feels like part of our extended family. This enduring commitment to quality and service has established Benkerts as a trusted name in bakery excellence across Centereach and surrounding communities.
Services
Fresh Pastries
Rolls and Bread
Custom Cakes
Layer Cakes
Cheesecakes
Coffee Cakes
Details
- Year established: 1924
Highlights and features
- Four generations of family baking tradition since 1924
- Specialists in custom cakes for special occasions
- Premium ingredients in all baked goods
- Reliable service with consistent quality
- Recognized as Long Island's finest bakery
Services
Custom Cakes
Our expert bakers create personalized custom cakes for weddings, birthdays, and special events. Using premium ingredients, we craft visually stunning and delicious cakes in any style or flavor. With decades of experience, our team ensures each creation perfectly matches your vision while maintaining exceptional taste and quality.
Fresh Pastries
We offer a wide selection of fresh pastries made daily using traditional recipes. From flaky croissants to buttery danishes, our pastries feature high-quality ingredients and perfect texture. Our rotating selection ensures customers enjoy consistently fresh and flavorful options throughout the day.
Layer Cakes
Our signature layer cakes combine moist cake layers with rich fillings and frostings. Available in classic flavors like chocolate and vanilla, each cake is carefully assembled to ensure balanced taste and presentation. Perfect for celebrations, these cakes showcase our commitment to traditional baking excellence.
Cheesecakes
We create creamy cheesecakes with smooth textures and rich flavors using premium dairy products. Our cheesecakes feature perfectly balanced crusts and fillings, available in traditional New York style and seasonal variations. Each cheesecake is baked to order for optimal freshness and quality.
Coffee Cakes
Our coffee cakes are made with quality ingredients and feature tender crumb textures with cinnamon streusel toppings. Available in various sizes and flavors, these cakes pair perfectly with coffee or tea. Baked fresh daily, they maintain the homemade quality that defines our bakery's reputation.
Questions
What are Benkerts' bakery hours?
We're open Monday-Friday 7:00am-6:00pm and Saturday-Sunday 6:00am-6:00pm.
Do you make custom wedding cakes?
Yes, our bakers specialize in custom wedding cakes with personalized designs and flavors.
What areas do you deliver to?
We serve all of Long Island with bakery delivery options available.
Are your baked goods made fresh daily?
All our pastries, cakes, and breads are baked fresh daily using premium ingredients.
Can I place special orders?
Yes, we accept special orders for custom cakes and specialty baked goods with advance notice.
Do you offer gluten-free options?
We have select gluten-free baked goods available - please check with our staff for current options.