Business Details
15 Years
experience
Custom Cakes & Desserts in Lyndhurst, NJ
Polkadot Cake Shop was founded in 2011 by Arlene Murray, who transitioned from a career in Human Resources Management and Marriage & Family Therapy to pursue her passion for baking. Our peanut-free custom bake shop specializes in creating visually stunning and flavorful desserts tailored to exceed client expectations. We use high-quality ingredients like real butter and pure Madagascar vanilla beans, baking in small batches to ensure freshness and quality. Our offerings include custom cakes, dessert tables, and themed decorating classes, serving events ranging from intimate gatherings to large-scale weddings.We operate from a custom cake studio in Lyndhurst, NJ, and our Polkadot Cupcake Truck provides mobile services for private events. Recognized by The Knot Best Of Weddings Hall of Fame and featured on Food Network and The Drew Barrymore Show, we combine artistic expertise with a commitment to customer satisfaction. Our team offers gluten-free and egg-free options, and we prioritize personalized service through consultations and tastings. With over a decade of experience, we continue to innovate while maintaining our dedication to edible artistry and exceptional flavor.
Services
Custom Cakes
Dessert Tables
Cupcake Truck Rentals
Themed Decorating Classes
Wedding Cakes
Allergen-Free Options
Cake Decorating Parties
Catering Services
Baking Workshops
Event Rentals
Details
- Year established: 2011
Highlights and features
- We offer peanut-free, gluten-free, and egg-free desserts with over a decade of baking expertise.
- Our team has won The Knot Best Of Weddings Hall of Fame recognition.
- We provide personalized consultations and tastings for custom orders.
- Our vintage cupcake truck delivers unique mobile dessert experiences.
- We use premium ingredients like real butter and Madagascar vanilla beans.
What people say
Stunning custom cakes
Peanut-free options available
Featured on Food Network
The Knot Hall of Fame
Vintage cupcake truck charm
Services
Custom Cakes
We create custom cakes for weddings, birthdays, and events using premium ingredients. Our designs range from elegant buttercream to intricate fondant work. Clients receive personalized consultations to ensure their vision is realized with exceptional flavor and presentation.
Dessert Tables
Custom dessert tables feature cupcakes, cookies, macarons, and themed treats for events. We provide rental displays and setup services. Options include gluten-free and allergen-free items, with pricing based on guest count and location.
Themed Classes
Our decorating classes teach buttercream and fondant techniques for adults and children. Public Cake & Sip events start at $85, while private parties include instruction and materials for group celebrations.
Cupcake Truck
The Polkadot Cupcake Truck delivers desserts to events with a rustic vintage camper setup. Available for weddings and private functions, it offers on-site service and display options for custom orders.
Allergen-Free Options
We provide gluten-free, egg-free, and peanut-free desserts with advance notice. These options maintain the same quality and design standards as our regular menu items, ensuring inclusivity for all dietary needs.
People
Arlene Murray
Owner & Lead Cake Designer
Arlene founded Polkadot Cake Shop in 2011 after careers in HR and therapy. Self-taught in baking, she specializes in buttercream and fondant designs. She expanded the business to include a food truck and custom studio.
Questions
What allergen-free options do you offer?
We provide peanut-free desserts with gluten-free and egg-free options available by request, using dedicated preparation methods to prevent cross-contamination.
How far in advance should I order a custom cake?
We recommend placing custom cake orders at least two weeks in advance, though we may accommodate shorter timelines depending on availability.
Do you deliver outside Lyndhurst, NJ?
Yes, we deliver within Northern NJ, parts of central NJ, and some areas of New York. Delivery fees start at $25 based on distance from our Lyndhurst location.
Can I rent display equipment for desserts?
We offer rental displays including towers, platters, and backdrops for dessert tables. Setup services are available upon request for events.
What types of decorating classes do you host?
We offer public Cake & Sip events, private adult parties, and kid-friendly decorating classes. Themes vary, with options for birthdays, team building, and special occasions.