Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Monroe, MI
Schafer Agency has served Monroe County for over a century, providing personalized insurance solutions to individuals and businesses. Founded in 1926, our agency represents carefully selected A-rated insurance carriers, enabling us to deliver comprehensive coverage tailored to each client's unique needs. Our mission focuses on risk management, identifying coverage gaps, and delivering value that protects clients' assets and future. With three convenient locations and a team of licensed professionals, we combine generational expertise with modern insurance strategies. Our agents specialize in auto, home, life, recreational vehicle, and business insurance, including niche offerings like farm policies and directors' liability coverage.We prioritize client education, ensuring policyholders understand their coverage options and make informed decisions. Our 100-year legacy reflects our commitment to treating every client with respect while maintaining transparency in all communications. The agency's four-generation family ownership ensures continuity in service standards and community engagement. We differentiate ourselves through dedicated personal service, competitive pricing, and a proven track record of successfully serving hundreds of satisfied customers. Our team's extensive knowledge of insurance carriers and policy structures allows us to shop effectively on behalf of clients, securing optimal coverage at fair prices.
Services
Auto Insurance
Homeowners Insurance
Life Insurance
Business Insurance
Recreational Vehicle Insurance
Farm Insurance
Workers Compensation
Commercial Property
General Liability
Business Owners Policy
Details
- Year established: 1926
Highlights and features
- We offer 100 years of combined insurance expertise in Monroe County
- Our team represents only A-rated insurance carriers for reliability
- We provide customized policy solutions, not cookie-cutter coverage
- Our licensed agents handle all aspects of insurance shopping for you
- We maintain deep local market knowledge for Monroe County risks
What people say
Professionalism
Quality
Responsiveness
Value
Top notch service
Services
Auto Insurance
Our auto insurance policies protect Michigan drivers against financial losses from accidents, theft, or vehicle damage. We offer comprehensive coverage options including liability protection, collision coverage, and uninsured motorist provisions. Our agents help clients navigate state requirements while securing competitive rates tailored to individual driving profiles and vehicle types.
Business Insurance
We provide customized business insurance solutions protecting Michigan companies against industry-specific risks. Coverage options include general liability, workers compensation, commercial property, and directors & officers liability. Our agents help businesses assess risk exposure and implement comprehensive protection strategies that safeguard assets and ensure operational continuity.
Homeowners Insurance
Our homeowners insurance policies protect Monroe County properties against damage from covered perils like fire, theft, and severe weather. Coverage includes dwelling protection, personal property replacement, and liability coverage for accidents occurring on insured properties. We help clients understand policy riders and ensure adequate coverage for their specific home protection needs.
Life Insurance
We offer term and permanent life insurance solutions providing financial security for beneficiaries. Our policies include death benefits for income replacement, funeral expenses, and estate planning. Agents help clients evaluate whole life, universal life, and term options to match their long-term financial goals and family protection requirements.
Recreational Vehicle Insurance
Our RV insurance covers motorhomes, travel trailers, and specialty vehicles against collision damage, theft, and liability claims. Policies protect against roadside emergencies and include coverage for personal belongings inside the vehicle. We help clients understand state requirements and select appropriate protection levels for their recreational vehicle investments.
People
Greg Schafer
Licensed Agent
With decades of insurance experience, Greg Schafer provides expert guidance on personal and commercial insurance solutions. He specializes in matching clients with appropriate coverage while maintaining transparent pricing standards.
Brenda Schuster
Elite Licensed Agent
Brenda Schuster combines technical expertise with personalized service, helping clients navigate insurance options. Her 20+ years of experience ensure thorough understanding of policy details and client needs.
Larry Schafer
Licensed Agent
Larry Schafer brings advanced credentials including CPCU and CIC designations to complex insurance planning. His expertise covers risk management strategies for both personal and business insurance portfolios.
Donna Dyda
Licensed Agent
Donna Dyda assists clients with insurance needs using her extensive knowledge of coverage options. She focuses on simplifying the insurance selection process while ensuring comprehensive protection.
Tony Marvaso
Licensed Agent
Tony Marvaso provides insurance solutions with attention to detail and client education. He helps individuals and businesses understand policy terms while securing competitive coverage options.
Questions
What types of insurance does Schafer Agency offer?
We offer auto, home, life, business, recreational vehicle, farm, workers compensation, and specialty insurance policies tailored to Michigan residents and businesses.
How can Schafer Agency help me find the right policy?
Our licensed agents compare options from multiple A-rated carriers to find customized coverage that matches your specific protection needs and budget.
Do you serve areas outside Monroe County?
While based in Monroe, we serve clients throughout Michigan with insurance solutions meeting regional risk profiles and regulatory requirements.
How do I file an insurance claim?
Contact our office directly and our team will guide you through the claims process, working with your insurer to resolve claims efficiently.
What makes Schafer Agency different from online insurers?
We provide personalized service with local expertise, offering face-to-face consultations and ongoing support that online-only providers cannot match.
Can you help with business insurance requirements?
Yes, we specialize in commercial insurance packages including liability, property, and workers compensation coverage tailored to Michigan businesses' specific needs.
