Business Details
18 Years
experience
Authentic Italian Dining in Lexington, KY
Since 2008, our family has proudly carried forward a multi-generational tradition of Italian culinary excellence rooted in the Mastarone family's heritage. With over 33 years of hands-on experience in Central Kentucky's restaurant industry, Gordon Lewis leads our team in delivering authentic, made-from-scratch Italian cuisine using locally sourced ingredients. Our commitment to quality is evident in every hand-crafted dish, from our signature meatballs to our bourbon-glazed salmon, all prepared using time-honored family recipes. We maintain direct relationships with local farmers and bakers to ensure farm-to-table freshness while preserving traditional Italian cooking methods. Our catering division extends this culinary expertise to weddings, corporate events, and private gatherings across Kentucky and the Midwest.The restaurant's warm, family-centric atmosphere reflects our core belief that meals should be shared experiences filled with tradition and connection. Through consistent quality and personalized service, we've become a trusted dining destination where regulars feel like family. Our menu balances classic Italian staples with innovative creations, all made using fresh, never-frozen ingredients. From Sunday family pasta nights to custom catering solutions, we strive to create memorable culinary experiences that honor our heritage while serving modern diners' needs. This dedication to authentic Italian hospitality has made us a Lexington staple for over 15 years.
Services
Italian Restaurant
Catering Services
Bar & Cocktails
Wine Selection
Private Events
Farm-to-Table Dining
Custom Pasta
Sunday Family Meals
Wedding Catering
Corporate Catering
Details
- Year established: 2008
Highlights and features
- We offer 33 years of hands-on experience in Kentucky's restaurant industry
- Our menu features house-made pasta and sauces prepared daily from scratch
- We maintain direct relationships with local farmers for daily fresh produce deliveries
- Our catering division serves weddings, corporate events, and private gatherings
- We combine traditional Italian recipes with modern culinary techniques
Services
Italian Restaurant
Our family-owned restaurant serves authentic Italian cuisine made from scratch using generations-old recipes and fresh, locally sourced ingredients. We offer a warm, inviting atmosphere where guests can enjoy classic dishes like hand-crafted meatballs, house-ground sausage, and daily-prepared pasta sauces. The menu features both traditional Italian favorites and innovative creations, with options for lunch, dinner, and special Sunday family meals.
Catering Services
We provide full-service catering for weddings, corporate events, and private gatherings with customized Italian menus. Our catering team handles everything from intimate home dinners to large-scale events at venues across Kentucky. We offer hot, freshly prepared dishes delivered ready to serve, including family-style platters, buffet setups, and formal plated meals that reflect our restaurant's quality standards.
Bar & Cocktails
Our bar features an extensive selection of wines, craft cocktails, and specialty drinks that complement our Italian menu. Guests can enjoy classic cocktails with Italian twists like the Italian Margarita featuring Amaretto, or our signature Sutton's Relaxer with coconut rum and peach schnapps. The wine list includes both Italian imports and domestic varietals, with options available by the glass or bottle to suit every palate.
Private Events
We specialize in hosting special occasions including weddings, rehearsal dinners, and corporate events in our restaurant space or at external venues. Our event planning team coordinates menu customization, seating arrangements, and service logistics to create memorable experiences. We offer flexible options for both seated dinners and cocktail-style receptions with attentive service that maintains our family restaurant's personal touch.
Farm-to-Table Dining
We maintain direct relationships with local farmers and producers to source the freshest ingredients for our daily menus. This commitment ensures seasonal produce, high-quality meats, and artisanal products that enhance our Italian dishes. Our kitchen staff works closely with suppliers to maintain consistent quality while supporting Kentucky agriculture, resulting in meals that showcase both Italian tradition and regional freshness.
Questions
What type of cuisine does Sutton's offer?
We specialize in authentic Italian cuisine with a Kentucky twist, featuring made-from-scratch pasta, house-ground meats, and locally sourced ingredients.
Do you offer catering services?
Yes, our catering division serves weddings, corporate events, and private gatherings with customized Italian menus for any occasion.
Are there vegetarian options available?
Yes, we offer several vegetarian dishes including Pasta Giovanni, Eggplant Parmesan, and seasonal vegetable preparations.
Can I create my own pasta dish?
Yes, our Create Your Own Pasta option lets you choose from three noodle types, two sauces, and multiple toppings including meat, seafood, and vegetables.
Do you have wine and cocktail options?
Yes, we offer an extensive wine list featuring Italian and domestic varietals, plus signature cocktails like the Italian Margarita and Sutton's Relaxer.
Is there a private dining area?
Yes, we can host special events and private gatherings with customized menus for weddings, reunions, and corporate functions.
