Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Custom Wedding Cakes & Artisan Pastries in Harrisonburg, VA
Bittersweet Bakery was founded on the principles of exceptional quality, locally sourced ingredients, and a passion for pastry. With over 30 years of combined experience, our co-owners Alicia and Erica bring expertise honed at prestigious institutions like the Biltmore Estate and Le Cordon Bleu. We specialize in scratch-made baked goods inspired by family recipes, offering a rotating weekly menu of pastries, custom wedding cakes, and event desserts. Our commitment to excellence is reflected in our meticulous attention to detail, from flavor development to artistic presentation.

We serve Harrisonburg, Charlottesville, and the Shenandoah Valley through online orders, weekend pickup, and on-site catering. Our team prioritizes personalized service, ensuring every client receives tailored solutions for their special occasions. By blending classic techniques with modern creativity, we deliver desserts that exceed expectations while maintaining the warmth of homemade tradition. Our reputation for reliability and quality has been built through years of dedicated service to our community.
Services
Custom Wedding Cakes Artisan Pastries Seasonal Desserts Catering Services Cake Tastings Baked Goods French Macarons Savory Items Bread Selections Mini Dessert Platters
Highlights and features
  • We offer 30+ years of combined experience from Biltmore Estate-trained pastry chefs
  • Our scratch-made desserts use locally sourced ingredients whenever possible
  • We provide personalized wedding cake consultations with tasting boxes available
  • Our rotating weekly menu ensures fresh, seasonal offerings
  • We deliver custom orders with 48-hour notice for catering and events
What people say
Exceptional taste Stunning artwork Professional service Creative themes Delicious desserts
Services
Custom Wedding Cakes
We create bespoke wedding cakes tailored to each couple's vision. Our offerings include tiered masterpieces, rustic naked cakes, and modern designs with custom color matching. Couples can choose from multiple flavors and fillings during our to-go tasting process. With a 50% deposit and final details confirmed two weeks before events, we ensure exceptional quality for weddings up to 200 guests.
Artisan Pastries
Our rotating selection of scratch-made pastries features both classic and innovative options. Daily offerings include eclairs, lemon tarts, fruit tarts, and seasonal specialties. All items use locally sourced ingredients and traditional baking methods. Custom orders with 48-hour notice accommodate special dietary needs and event requirements.
Seasonal Desserts
We craft seasonal dessert collections that highlight local produce and holiday themes. Current offerings include lemon lavender creations, Mother's Day tea pastries, and graduation celebration desserts. Our menu updates weekly to showcase fresh ingredients and creative flavor combinations while maintaining our signature homemade quality.
Catering Services
We provide dessert catering for weddings, corporate events, and private parties. Services include dessert bars, mini cheesecake assortments, and custom cookie platters. Our team coordinates with event planners to ensure proper quantities and presentation. Advance orders guarantee availability for specific menu items.
Cake Tastings
Our tasting process includes three cake and filling options in convenient to-go boxes. Couples receive personalized consultations to discuss design ideas, flavor combinations, and event logistics. Additional tasting options are available for extra fees, with final flavor selections confirmed two weeks before wedding dates.
People
Alicia Barger
Co-Owner/Pastry Chef
Alicia brings 15+ years of experience from prestigious venues like the Peabody Hotel and Biltmore Estate. She developed her skills through hands-on training and learned quality ingredient appreciation during her eight years at Biltmore. She co-founded Bittersweet Bakery with Erica in 2018.
Erica Ray
Co-Owner/Pastry Chef
Erica trained at Le Cordon Bleu in patisserie and gained experience at the Inn on Biltmore Estate and the Inn at Little Washington. She combines formal education with creative innovation, bringing technical expertise to Bittersweet Bakery's custom cake designs and pastry creations.
Questions
Do you offer cake tastings for weddings?
Yes, we provide to-go tasting boxes with 3 cake and 3 filling options. Additional flavors available for extra fees.
How far in advance should I book my wedding cake?
We recommend booking at least 6 months in advance, especially for summer weddings. Deposit required to secure dates.
Can I customize my wedding cake design?
All cakes are customized to your vision. We accept design changes up to 2 weeks before your event.
Do you deliver wedding cakes?
Yes, we deliver and set up wedding cakes. We typically don't cut cakes unless requested for additional fee.
What payment options are available?
We require 50% non-refundable deposit with remaining balance due 2 weeks before your event.
Do you offer alternative dessert options?
Yes, we provide dessert bars with macarons, mini cheesecakes, pies, and custom cookie platters.