Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Custom Cakes & Desserts in Glen Ellyn, IL
Vanilla Sugar Bakery was born from a lifelong passion for baking that began in childhood. Our founders, Maggie and Norma, were inspired by cherished memories of baking with their father, which sparked their dedication to creating high-quality confections. We operate a flagship store and online platform to share our creativity and passion with a wider audience. Every item is baked fresh daily in our on-site kitchen using premium ingredients, from buttercream to fillings. Our walk-in display is open Thursday through Saturday, offering same-day pickup options from our weekly menu.

Custom orders require advance notice, with availability typically booked several weeks in advance. We prioritize quality, freshness, and customer satisfaction in every recipe we create. Our small family-run business aims to bring joy through sweet confections for celebrations or everyday cravings. We appreciate customer support and strive to maintain transparent communication through our stated policies. Orders can be placed online year-round with seasonal availability, and we encourage early bookings to ensure timely fulfillment.
Services
Custom Cakes Cupcakes Desserts Online Orders Same Day Pickup Signature Cakes Wedding Cakes Birthday Cakes Seasonal Desserts
Highlights and features
  • We use only the highest quality ingredients in every recipe
  • Our baked goods are made fresh daily on-site
  • We offer custom cake and dessert orders with advance notice
  • Our online store allows easy ordering for future dates
  • We are a family-owned business committed to quality
Services
Custom Cakes
We create personalized custom cakes for special occasions using premium ingredients. Our design process ensures each cake matches your vision while maintaining exceptional taste. Available with advance booking through our online ordering system.
Cupcakes
Daily fresh-baked cupcakes made with high-quality buttercream and fillings. Available in regular and seasonal flavors through walk-in display hours or same-day pickup options.
Online Orders
Our online store provides year-round ordering with date availability several months in advance. Customers can select from weekly menus or request custom arrangements at any time.
Same Day Pickup
Selected weekly menu items available for immediate pickup Thursday through Saturday. Orders must be placed before closing times during walk-in display hours.
Signature Cakes
Pre-designed signature cakes showcase our creative expertise using fresh daily ingredients. Available through both online ordering and in-store display selections during operating hours.
People
Maggie Walk-In
Co-Owner
Co-founder Maggie Walk-In brings childhood baking memories to our daily operations. She oversees recipe development and maintains quality standards for all products.
Norma Walk-In
Co-Owner
Co-founder Norma Walk-In shares responsibility for business operations with her sister. She focuses on customer relations and ensures our service policies meet family standards.
Questions
What types of custom orders do you accept?
We accept custom cake and dessert orders with 1-3 weeks notice. Wedding cakes, birthday creations, and specialty designs require advance booking.
When can I pick up same-day orders?
Same-day pickup from our weekly menu is available Wednesday through Saturday during walk-in display hours.
What ingredients do you use in your baking?
We use only the highest quality ingredients including fresh buttercream, premium fillings, and carefully selected baking components daily.
Are you open year-round?
Our online store operates year-round. Physical location is closed Sundays through Tuesdays for restocking and preparation.
How far in advance should I place orders?
We recommend placing orders as early as possible, especially around holidays when 3-week notice becomes standard for custom requests.