Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Italian Restaurant in Midland Park Since 1970
Brothers Pizzeria has been a cornerstone of Midland Park, NJ, since 1970, offering authentic Southern Italian cuisine rooted in family tradition. Founded by Nino and Anna Mazzola, our pizzeria began as a humble 'Mom and Pop' shop and has grown into a beloved local institution while preserving the classic recipes and techniques passed down through generations. Our commitment to quality is evident in every dish, crafted with fresh, seasonal ingredients and time-honored methods perfected over decades. Today, Ninos son Anthony and son-in-law Roberto lead our team, blending Sicilian heritage with contemporary flair to deliver unforgettable dining experiences.We pride ourselves on creating a warm, family-friendly atmosphere where guests can enjoy generous portions at reasonable prices, whether in our rustic farmhouse setting, on our seasonal outdoor patio, or through our full-service catering. With 45 years of dedication to excellence, we remain steadfast in our mission to serve the community with passion, integrity, and a deep respect for Italian culinary traditions.
Services
Italian Restaurant
Catering Services
Gift Cards
Online Ordering
Outdoor Dining
Details
- Year established: 1970
Highlights and features
- We offer 45 years of expertise in Southern Italian cooking with family recipes.
- Our menu features handcrafted pizzas cooked in brick-lined ovens for perfect texture.
- We provide full-service catering with customizable menus for any event.
- Our rustic, family-friendly ambiance accommodates both intimate and communal dining.
- We use fresh, seasonal ingredients sourced to maintain Sicilian culinary authenticity.
Services
Italian Restaurant
Brothers Pizzeria offers a family-friendly Italian dining experience with a menu rooted in Southern Italian traditions. Our dishes feature handcrafted pizzas cooked in brick ovens, Sicilian specialties, and homemade pastas made with fresh, seasonal ingredients. The rustic farmhouse ambiance, complete with communal and traditional seating, creates a welcoming environment for all occasions. Whether dining in or ordering takeout, guests enjoy generous portions at reasonable prices, reflecting our commitment to quality and authenticity.
Catering Services
We provide full-service catering for events in Midland Park and surrounding areas, specializing in Southern Italian cuisine with a contemporary twist. Our customizable menus include handcrafted pizzas, antipasti, pastas, and Sicilian specialties, served with chafing dishes, sternos, and racks. On-site events accommodate up to 40 guests in two private rooms, while off-site catering includes setup and equipment delivery. Our team ensures seamless execution, offering servers and flexible options to suit any budget or occasion.
Outdoor Dining
Enjoy our seasonal outdoor patio from April through October, offering a relaxed setting to savor our Italian menu. The patio complements our rustic farmhouse interior, providing additional seating for guests seeking fresh air and a casual atmosphere. Perfect for lunch, dinner, or weekend gatherings, our outdoor space maintains the same commitment to quality and tradition as our indoor dining room, with the added charm of al fresco dining.
Gift Cards
Brothers Pizzeria offers refillable gift cards available in any amount, ideal for birthdays, holidays, or special occasions. Cards can be purchased in-store or ordered by phone for direct mailing to the recipient. With no expiration date, our gift cards provide flexibility for future visits. Please note that gift cards cannot be used for gratuities, and we recommend safeguarding them as we do not replace lost or stolen cards.
Online Ordering
Our online ordering system allows customers to conveniently access our full menu for pickup or delivery. From classic pizzas and Sicilian dishes to appetizers and desserts, orders are prepared fresh and efficiently. The platform supports easy customization and secure payment, ensuring a seamless experience. This service extends our commitment to accessibility, enabling guests to enjoy our Italian cuisine from the comfort of their homes or offices.
People
Nino Mazzola
Founder
Nino Mazzola founded the business in 1970 after emigrating from Italy. A self-taught pizzaiolo, he built the restaurant from a small pizzeria into a community staple. Though retired from daily operations, he still joins the team on busy nights, sharing his passion for traditional Italian cooking.
Anthony Mazzola
Owner
Anthony Mazzola, Ninos son, grew up in the business and now leads Brothers Pizzeria. With a background in international business, he oversaw the 2012 expansion into a larger space. He ensures the restaurant maintains its commitment to quality while adapting to modern customer needs.
Roberto Mannino
Co-Owner
Roberto Mannino, a native of Sicily, joined the team in 2000 after marrying Ninos daughter Vera. He mastered Sicilian pizza-making in his cousins pizzeria and now contributes his culinary expertise to the menu. His focus on fresh, seasonal ingredients reflects his upbringing in Italy.
Vera Mannino
Chef
Vera Mannino, Ninos daughter, co-founded the business with her father and husband Roberto. Her Sicilian-inspired recipes form the backbone of the menu. After living in Italy for a decade, she returned to the U.S. to help expand the business, blending family traditions with new ideas.
Questions
What type of cuisine does Pizzaiolo by Brothers specialize in?
We specialize in Southern Italian cuisine, including handcrafted pizzas, Sicilian specialties, and traditional Italian dishes made with fresh ingredients.
Do you offer catering services for events?
Yes, we provide full-service catering with customizable menus, including on-site and off-site options for events up to 40 guests.
Can I order food online?
Yes, we offer online ordering for our full menu, including pizzas, pastas, and Italian specialties, available for pickup or delivery.
Are gift cards available for purchase?
Yes, we offer refillable gift cards in any amount, which can be purchased in-store or mailed directly to you by phone.
Is outdoor dining available year-round?
Our outdoor patio is seasonally available from April through October, weather permitting.
