Business Details
Authentic New York-Style Pizza & Italian Favorites
At Stephens Pizzeria, we take pride in crafting New York-style pizzas using a cherished 50-year-old family recipe that has been perfected over generations. Our commitment to quality begins with daily preparation of fresh ingredients, including house-made dough, hand-sliced vegetables, and premium cuts of meat. Our seasoned sausage and hamburger are made in-house, while our signature buttery blended cheese elevates every bite. We approach pizza-making as an art form, ensuring each pie reflects our dedication to authenticity and excellence. Our menu extends beyond pizza to include handcrafted hoagies, fresh salads, homemade pasta dishes, and decadent desserts, all prepared with the same meticulous attention to detail. With decades of experience in the culinary industry, we combine traditional techniques with modern innovation to deliver consistently exceptional results.Our team of skilled pizza artisans brings deep expertise in Italian cuisine, ensuring every dish meets the highest standards of flavor and quality. We are recognized in Gray, TN, for our unwavering commitment to using only the freshest ingredients and maintaining the integrity of our time-honored recipe. Our establishment operates with complete transparency, offering fair pricing and honest service that has earned us a loyal customer base. We stand behind every meal we serve, guaranteeing satisfaction through our dedication to culinary excellence and customer-centric values.
Services
New York Style Pizza
Italian Hoagies
Fresh Salads
Homemade Pasta
Desserts
Highlights and features
- We use a 50-year-old family pizza recipe perfected through generations.
- All dough, sauces, and ingredients are made fresh daily in-house.
- Our buttery blended cheese creates a uniquely memorable flavor profile.
- We hand-select premium cuts of beef and pork for our meats.
- Awarded 'Best in Show' by local customers for our BBQ Chicken pizza.
What people say
BEST PIZZA IN THE TRI-CITIES
Great Pizza & Wings
Fresh ingredients
Fair prices
Friendly staff
Services
New York Style Pizza
Our hand-tossed New York-style pizzas feature a 50-year-old family recipe with house-made dough and signature buttery cheese blend. Premium meats and fresh vegetables are added daily to ensure authentic flavor. Each pie reflects decades of culinary expertise in traditional Italian pizza-making techniques.
Italian Hoagies
Handcrafted hoagies combine grilled black forest ham, pepperoni, bacon, and house-made meatballs with fresh vegetables and specialty sauces. Every sandwich uses locally sourced ingredients to deliver bold, authentic Italian flavors in every bite.
Fresh Salads
Daily-prepared salads feature crisp greens, hand-sliced vegetables, and premium proteins like sweet barbecue chicken or seasoned steak. Our dressings and marinara sauces are made from scratch to complement each ingredient perfectly.
Homemade Pasta
Traditional pasta dishes include house-made spaghetti served with fresh marinara sauce and cheese toast. Our recipes preserve Italian culinary heritage while using modern techniques to ensure consistent quality and flavor excellence.
Desserts
Decadent desserts like homemade tiramisu and chocolate cannoli showcase our commitment to Italian pastry traditions. Every treat uses fresh ingredients and time-tested methods to deliver authentic, memorable flavors.
Questions
What makes Stephens Pizzeria's pizza authentic New York-style?
Our hand-tossed crust uses a 50-year-old family recipe with house-made dough and signature cheese blend, replicating traditional Brooklyn pizzeria techniques.
Do you offer catering services for events?
Yes, we provide catering with custom menus featuring our New York-style pizzas, hoagies, and fresh salads for parties and gatherings.
Are all ingredients prepared fresh daily?
Yes, we make dough nightly, slice vegetables daily, and prepare meats and sauces on-site to ensure maximum freshness and quality.
What are your current specialty pizzas?
Featured pizzas include Big Babbo with sausage and peppers, LG Jamaican Jerk with pineapple, and Mega Meat with five premium meats.
Do you have vegetarian pizza options?
Yes, our Margherita pizza features fresh mozzarella and house-made marinara on our signature crust, with vegetable toppings available upon request.
