Business Details
41 Years
experience
Family-Owned Pizzeria Since 1985
Since 1985, Ficarella's Pizzeria has been Batavia's premier family-run pizzeria, combining decades of culinary expertise with a commitment to quality ingredients and community service. Our menu features handcrafted pizzas, fresh subs, house-made pasta, and daily specials, all prepared with care to ensure consistency and customer satisfaction. We pioneered Batavia's first pizza drive-thru window, offering convenient service without compromising on taste or quality. Our loyalty program rewards repeat customers with tangible benefits, including free menu items earned through purchases. With over 40 years of operation, we maintain a reputation for exceptional food, friendly service, and a welcoming atmosphere that keeps customers returning.Our team takes pride in creating memorable dining experiences, whether through our sit-down restaurant, delivery service, or innovative drive-up window. We actively engage with the local community, sourcing fresh ingredients and supporting neighborhood initiatives. Our dedication to excellence has earned us consistent recognition as Batavia's top pizza destination, with a loyal customer base that spans generations. We maintain rigorous quality control standards while continuously innovating our menu to reflect evolving tastes and preferences. Our staff receives ongoing training to uphold our service standards, ensuring every customer interaction meets our high expectations.
Services
Pizza
Subs
Pasta
Fish Fries
Salads
Specialty Sandwiches
Drive-Thru Service
Online Ordering
Loyalty Program
Details
- Year established: 1985
Highlights and features
- We've served Batavia with fresh, quality pizza for over 40 years
- Our drive-thru window offers unique convenience without compromising food quality
- Loyalty program rewards customers with free menu items through purchases
- Daily specials keep our menu exciting and value-driven
- Consistently recognized as Batavia's top pizza destination by locals
What people say
Best pizza in town
Fast and polite service
Drive up window
Great food
Best pizzas
Services
Pizza
Our pizza menu features hand-tossed, Sicilian, and specialty pizzas made with fresh dough and premium toppings. Each pie combines traditional recipes with modern flavor profiles to satisfy diverse tastes. Customers consistently praise our crust quality and sauce consistency, with options ranging from classic cheese to elaborate combinations.
Subs
Hot and cold subs feature quality meats, cheeses, and house-made dressings on freshly baked bread. The menu includes traditional favorites and unique creations that showcase our culinary creativity. Many customers specifically mention our subs as a standout alternative to standard deli offerings.
Pasta
House-made pasta dishes include classic Italian staples and regional specialties prepared with homemade sauces. Our rotating menu features both traditional recipes and contemporary interpretations that highlight seasonal ingredients. The pasta section consistently receives praise for its generous portions and authentic flavors.
Fish Fries
Weekly fish fry specials offer crispy, golden-battered seafood with traditional sides and dipping sauces. This menu staple attracts regular customers during specific service hours, featuring both standard preparations and unique variations that differentiate us from other local establishments.
Drive-Thru Service
Batavia's only pizza drive-thru window provides fast, convenient access to our full menu without leaving your vehicle. This innovative service option maintains our quality standards while offering time-saving benefits for busy customers. The drive-thru consistently receives positive feedback for its efficiency and order accuracy.
Questions
What makes Ficarella's Pizzeria unique in Batavia?
We're Batavia's oldest family-run pizzeria with a drive-thru window, offering fresh, handcrafted pizzas since 1985 while maintaining consistent quality and community focus.
What loyalty program benefits are available?
Earn points per purchase toward free menu items including pizzas, fries, and appetizers, with automatic birthday pizza rewards for registered members.
What are the most popular menu items?
Customers consistently praise our Sicilian pizza, calzones, wings, and specialty subs, though our rotating daily specials also attract regular attention.
What service options do you offer?
We provide dine-in, delivery, and Batavia's only pizza drive-thru window with online ordering available for all service types.
What are your current operating hours?
We're open Monday-Wednesday 3 PM-10 PM and Sunday, Thursday-Saturday 11 AM-10 PM.
