Experience the authentic taste of Naples Italy on Nantucket
Our Story
At Pi Pizzeria, our story begins with a passion for traditional Neapolitan pizza and a desire to share that passion with the community. Our journey started in the early 2000s, when our founder, Evan Marley, had the vision to bring a taste of Naples, Italy to Nantucket Island. After years of perfecting the art of wood-fired pizza making, we opened the doors to our cozy pizzeria in the heart of Nantucket. Today, we're proud to serve our guests with the same dedication to quality and authenticity that we've always had.
Our Menu
Our menu is designed to take you on a culinary journey through the Italian countryside. We're passionate about traditional Neapolitan pizza making, using only the finest ingredients and cooking techniques passed down from generations. Our pizzas are cooked in our wood-fired brick oven, giving them a unique flavor and texture that will leave you craving more. From classic margherita to more adventurous options like our famous esposito's sausage pizza, we're confident that you'll find something to love.
Lunch and Dinner Options
At Pi Pizzeria, we believe that every meal should be a celebration of life. That's why we offer a range of lunch and dinner options to suit every taste and dietary requirement. From our famous wood-fired pizzas to our delicious pasta dishes and cold subs, there's something for everyone at our table. Whether you're in the mood for a heartwarming bowl of minestrone or a flavorful plate of chicken parmesan, we've got you covered.
Special Diets
We understand that eating out can be a challenge for those with special dietary needs. That's why we make every effort to accommodate our guests with gluten-free, vegetarian, and vegan options. Our knowledgeable staff is happy to guide you through our menu and make recommendations based on your dietary requirements. We're committed to providing a welcoming and inclusive dining environment for all.
Take-Out and Delivery
At Pi Pizzeria, we believe that great food should be accessible to everyone. That's why we offer take-out and delivery options for those who prefer to enjoy our food from the comfort of their own homes. Our take-out menu features a range of options, from our famous wood-fired pizzas to our delicious pasta dishes. We're proud to partner with local delivery services to bring our food right to your doorstep.
Hours and Location
We're open six days a week, from 11:30 AM to 9:00 PM, with the exception of Tuesdays. We're located at 11 West Creek Road on beautiful Nantucket Island. Whether you're a local or just visiting, we can't wait to welcome you to our cozy pizzeria.
About Us
At Pi Pizzeria, we're passionate about sharing the flavors and traditions of Italy with our community. We believe that food should be a celebration of life, and we're committed to providing a warm and welcoming atmosphere for every guest. From the moment you walk through our doors, we'll treat you like family.
General Overview
The reviews for PI Pizzeria on Nantucket are mixed, with both positive and negative comments. The restaurant is praised for its great people, delicious food, and accommodating staff. However, some reviewers have experienced negative interactions with staff, lengthy wait times, and unsatisfactory food quality.
Food Quality and Presentation
Several reviewers have praised the restaurant's pizza, citing its thin crust, delicious sauce, and well-balanced toppings. Some reviewers, however, have reported disappointment with the pizza's appearance, with one reviewer describing it as "jar sauce spread on cardboard." Others have praised the salads and desserts, while one reviewer was disappointed with the lack of basil on their margarita pizza.
Service and Ambiance
The service at PI Pizzeria has been a mixed bag, with some reviewers praising the friendly and attentive staff, while others have experienced poor service, including long wait times and poor communication. The atmosphere has been praised for its Italian ambiance, although one reviewer noted that the inside can get quite busy.
Value and Pricing
Some reviewers have noted that the prices at PI Pizzeria are high, although they are considered reasonable compared to the overall cost of living on Nantucket. Others have praised the value for the quality of food received.
Be the first to review Pi Pizzaria.
Write a Review
