Business Details
35 Years
experience
Your Trusted Pizza Destination in Sarasota
Since 1991, Shaner's Pizza has been a cornerstone of the Sarasota community, dedicated to serving handcrafted thin crust pizza made with the freshest ingredients. Founded by former MLB pitcher Shane Rawley, our pizzeria combines decades of culinary expertise with a passion for quality, offering a menu that extends beyond pizza to include gourmet sandwiches, fresh salads, and house-made appetizers. Our commitment to excellence is reflected in every dish, from our signature thin crust creations to our carefully curated wine and craft beer selection.With a welcoming atmosphere enhanced by sports memorabilia from Shane's professional career, we provide a unique dining experience where customers can enjoy great food while engaging in conversations about baseball and local culture. Our dedication to community and customer satisfaction has made us a beloved destination for both residents and visitors seeking authentic, high-quality meals in a relaxed environment.
Services
Thin Crust Pizza
Takeout Service
Sports Bar
Gourmet Sandwiches
House-Made Appetizers
Details
- Year established: 1991
Highlights and features
- We've served Sarasota with quality pizza since 1991
- Our dough is made fresh daily with premium ingredients
- Owner Shane Rawley brings decades of baseball expertise
- We offer a unique sports-themed dining experience
- Our menu features house-made appetizers and gourmet sandwiches
Services
Thin Crust Pizza
Our signature thin crust pizza features hand-tossed dough made fresh daily, topped with premium ingredients and traditional Italian flavors. Each pie combines time-tested recipes with modern creativity, offering both classic combinations and unique specialty options. The crisp yet foldable crust provides the perfect foundation for generous portions of melted cheese and house-made sauces.
Takeout Service
Shaner's Pizza takeout service provides convenient access to our full menu of freshly prepared meals. Customers can order hot, ready-to-go pizzas and other menu items for pickup during our extended operating hours. The streamlined process ensures quick service without compromising food quality or temperature control.
Sports Bar
The sports bar features multiple screens broadcasting live games alongside our full menu of gourmet pizzas and sandwiches. Decorated with memorabilia from owner Shane Rawley's professional baseball career, the venue combines casual dining with immersive sports viewing experiences. The welcoming atmosphere accommodates both solo diners and groups.
Gourmet Sandwiches
Handcrafted sandwiches feature premium meats, fresh vegetables, and signature sauces on house-made buns. Options range from classic meatball hoagies to specialty creations like the Bourbon Bacon Jam Smash Burger. Each sandwich includes a choice of side items to complete the meal.
House-Made Appetizers
Appetizers include traditional favorites like mozzarella sticks and jalapeno poppers alongside unique house recipes. All items are prepared fresh to order using quality ingredients, with multiple sauce options available. The portion sizes work well for sharing or as meal starters.
People
Shane Rawley
Owner
Former MLB pitcher with 12 major league seasons who opened Shaner's Pizza in 1991. Combines baseball expertise with culinary passion, creating a unique dining experience that reflects his personal history and commitment to quality ingredients.
Questions
What are Shaner's operating hours?
We're open Monday-Saturday 11:30am-9pm and Sunday 3:30pm-9pm.
Do you offer takeout options?
Yes, we provide convenient takeout service with our full menu available for pickup.
What makes your pizza special?
Our thin crust pizza uses fresh daily dough and premium ingredients for authentic flavor.
Are there sports viewing options?
Multiple screens show live games in our sports-themed dining environment.
Do you serve sandwiches?
Yes, we offer gourmet sandwiches including meatball, chicken parmesan, and specialty burgers.
Is there a salad menu?
We feature several fresh salad options with house-made dressings and premium toppings.
