Fancy That Cake

Fancy That Cake has been crafting spectacular, custom cakes in the Tristate area since 2009. What began as a passion project - a desire to create stunningly beautiful cakes that tasted as good as they looked - blossomed into a thriving business. We take immense pride in being Southeast Missouri's go-to source for truly exceptional custom cakes, and we've had the distinct honor of contributing to over 400 weddings in the region.

Our Baking Philosophy

At Fancy That Cake, we believe a wedding cake is more than just a dessert; it's a reflection of your unique love story, a centerpiece that embodies the joy and elegance of your special day. Whether your vision is a grand, show-stopping spectacle worthy of a Hollywood celebration, bursting with glitter, glamour, and intricate details, or a charming rustic creation that exudes warmth and intimacy, we're here to bring your dreams to life.

From whimsical and playful designs to elegant and sophisticated creations, we specialize in crafting cakes that are as individual as the couple they celebrate. Our goal isn't to simply bake a cake; it's to create a work of art that will be cherished and remembered long after the last slice is enjoyed.

A Commitment to Perfection

We understand the importance of every detail on your wedding day. That's why we offer a complimentary cake sketch service, allowing you to visualize your dream cake before it takes shape. Our skilled artist, Katie Goodpasture, will meticulously hand-draw your cake design in Photoshop, ensuring every element aligns perfectly with your vision. This allows for collaborative refinement and ensures complete satisfaction before we begin baking.

We also believe that the cake tasting experience should be a delightful and interactive journey. It's not just about choosing flavors; it's about getting to know us, sharing your preferences, and ensuring that your cake reflects your unique taste.

And, because every cake deserves a perfect finale, we offer professional cake-cutting services to create a seamless and elegant presentation during your reception.

Meet Katie, Our Artist & Cake Creator

Katie's passion for cake artistry stems from a background in fine art. She sees every cake as a canvas, where flavor and form perfectly harmonize. This artistic perspective, combined with her dedication to using the finest ingredients and time-honored baking techniques, results in cakes that are both visually stunning and incredibly delicious.

Beyond her culinary skills, Katie possesses a genuine warmth and commitment to her clients. She truly listens to their desires, offering guidance and creative inspiration every step of the way.