Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Trusted Personal Injury Lawyers in Indianapolis
Poynter & Bucheri is a dedicated legal practice specializing in personal injury law, serving clients across Indiana. With decades of combined experience, our attorneys focus on representing individuals injured due to negligence, including car accidents, truck collisions, slip-and-fall incidents, and wrongful death claims. We prioritize client needs through strategic case handling, offering free case reviews and operating on a contingency fee basis to ensure accessibility.

Our team is committed to securing fair compensation for medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering while maintaining transparency and ethical standards. Headquartered in Indianapolis, we serve communities statewide, combining local knowledge with a track record of successful settlements and verdicts.
Services
Personal Injury Car Accidents Truck Accidents Motorcycle Accidents Slip and Fall Wrongful Death Dog Bite Injuries Dram Shop Liability Bicycle Accidents ATV Accidents
Highlights and features
  • We offer decades of experience in personal injury law with a focus on Indiana cases.
  • Our contingency fee of 25% ensures greater compensation for clients compared to industry standards.
  • Strategic case handling prioritizes client interests when evaluating insurance settlement offers.
  • Free case reviews provide immediate access to experienced legal guidance without upfront costs.
  • We serve clients statewide with local knowledge of Indiana's legal landscape and insurance practices.
What people say
Handled everything Fair settlement Professional and courteous Quick to inform Best personal injury attorneys
Services
Personal Injury
Our personal injury attorneys represent clients injured by negligence in car accidents, slip-and-fall incidents, and other scenarios. We pursue compensation for medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering. With decades of experience, we provide strategic legal guidance to maximize client recovery.
Car Accidents
We handle car accident cases involving rear-end collisions, hit-and-run incidents, and distracted driving. Our team evaluates liability, negotiates with insurance companies, and secures compensation for vehicle damage, medical bills, and lost income. Contingency fees ensure no upfront costs for clients.
Truck Accidents
Specializing in semi-truck and delivery vehicle accidents, we investigate liability involving overloaded cargo, blind spots, and driver fatigue. Our attorneys work with experts to prove negligence and recover damages for catastrophic injuries, property damage, and wrongful death claims.
Slip and Fall
We represent clients injured from unsafe property conditions like unshoveled snow, loose railings, and improper thresholds. Our team proves property owner negligence to secure compensation for medical treatment, rehabilitation costs, and lost earning capacity.
Wrongful Death
Our firm assists families pursuing wrongful death claims from car crashes, truck accidents, and dram shop liability. We help recover funeral expenses, lost financial support, and emotional damages while holding negligent parties accountable for preventable fatalities.
People
Donald L. Poynter
Personal Injury Attorney
Donald Poynter has decades of experience representing personal injury clients in Indiana. He focuses on car accidents, truck collisions, and slip-and-fall cases, prioritizing client communication and strategic case evaluation to maximize compensation.
Richard C. Bucheri
Personal Injury Attorney
Richard Bucheri specializes in personal injury litigation with a focus on catastrophic injuries and wrongful death claims. He provides honest case assessments and advocates for client rights against insurance companies and negligent parties.
John D. Norman
Personal Injury Attorney
John Norman represents clients in complex personal injury cases, including motorcycle accidents and premises liability. He combines legal expertise with compassionate client support to navigate the claims process effectively.
Pam Moon
Legal Assistant
Pam Moon supports personal injury cases by managing client correspondence, medical records, and case updates. With over a year at the firm, she assists attorneys in preparing documentation and communicating with insurance adjusters.
Nancy Heaton
Paralegal/Claims Specialist
Nancy Heaton has 12.5 years of experience as a litigation paralegal. She identifies insurance policies, prepares legal documents, and supports case management while maintaining focus on client needs and procedural accuracy.
Questions
What types of personal injury cases do you handle?
We handle car accidents, truck collisions, slip-and-fall injuries, dog bites, motorcycle accidents, and wrongful death claims across Indiana.
How much does it cost to hire your firm?
We work on contingency fees starting at 25% for car accident cases, with no attorney fees unless we win your case.
Do you offer free consultations?
Yes, we provide free case reviews to evaluate your claim and discuss legal options without upfront costs.
How long do injury cases typically take?
Case duration varies by complexity, but we prioritize efficient resolution while ensuring fair compensation for medical expenses and losses.
Can I afford legal representation?
Our contingency fee structure removes financial barriers, allowing access to experienced attorneys regardless of current financial situation.
What areas do you serve?
We represent clients throughout Indiana, including Indianapolis, Carmel, Fishers, Bloomington, and surrounding communities.