Business Details
36 Years
experience
Your Local Bakery for Fresh Baked Goods & Homemade Soup
Established in 1990, The Upper Crust Bake House Co has spent over three decades perfecting the art of homemade comfort food. Our commitment to natural ingredients and traditional preparation methods ensures every product reflects the care and quality of a bygone era. Jim and Colleen Mikula, our founders and recipe developers, personally oversee the creation of all soups, baked goods, and sandwiches using techniques passed down through generations. We roast fresh turkeys daily for our signature sandwiches, bake old-fashioned bread by hand, and prepare 4-6 unique soups from scratch each day without commercial starters. Our menu features over 20 varieties of artisanal pastries, including cinnamon buns, cherry turnovers, and lemon raspberry teacakes, all made using family recipes.Located in historic Fredonia, NY, we combine a cheery atmosphere with eclectic decor and free Wi-Fi to create a welcoming space for locals and visitors alike. Our dedication to inclusivity is evident in our extensive vegetarian options and select vegan offerings. Situated just three miles from Lake Erie beaches and along the regional wine trail, we serve as both a culinary destination and community hub. The combination of homemade quality, consistent innovation, and personalized service has made us a regional favorite for more than 30 years. Our staff's warmth and attention to detail ensure every customer experiences the 'love' that distinguishes our food and service.
Services
Bakery Items
Signature Soups
Sandwiches
Espresso Drinks
Catering Services
Details
- Year established: 1990
Highlights and features
- We've perfected homemade recipes for over 30 years
- Our soups are made daily from scratch with natural ingredients
- Hand-baked breads and pastries using family recipes
- Extensive vegetarian and vegan menu options available
- Cheery atmosphere with personalized service from sweet staff
What people say
Best cinnamon buns
Homemade quality
Cheery atmosphere
Fresh ingredients
Friendly staff
Services
Signature Soups
Our daily soups feature 4-6 rotating varieties made from scratch using natural ingredients and no commercial starters. Each recipe is crafted to highlight traditional flavors while maintaining modern quality standards. Customers consistently praise our ability to capture 'the love' in every bowl through careful preparation and ingredient selection.
Artisan Baked Goods
We produce over 20 varieties of handcrafted pastries including cinnamon buns, cherry turnovers, and lemon raspberry teacakes using family recipes. Our breads are baked fresh daily in traditional styles that emphasize texture and flavor. Each item reflects our commitment to maintaining 1900s-era baking techniques while meeting contemporary tastes.
Signature Sandwiches
Daily roasted turkeys provide the foundation for our signature sandwiches served on homemade bread. Each sandwich combines quality ingredients with our signature 'love' approach to preparation. The menu features both classic and innovative options that showcase our commitment to traditional food values.
Espresso Bar
Our espresso bar serves what locals call 'the best espresso in Chautauqua County' using premium beans and professional equipment. The menu includes traditional espresso drinks alongside seasonal specialty offerings. This service complements our food menu while standing as a destination feature for coffee enthusiasts.
Drop-Off Catering
We provide catering services featuring our signature soups, sandwiches, and baked goods for events and gatherings. The menu offers both standard packages and customized options to suit various occasions. This service extends our commitment to quality food beyond our physical location to serve community needs.
People
Jim Mikula
Co-Owner & Recipe Developer
Jim Mikula co-founded The Upper Crust in 1990 and personally develops all soup and bakery recipes. He oversees daily food preparation and maintains quality standards across all products. His commitment to traditional methods ensures every item reflects authentic craftsmanship.
Colleen Mikula
Co-Owner & Customer Experience
Colleen Mikula, co-founder and face of the business, focuses on customer relations and staff development. She created the establishment's welcoming atmosphere and maintains the 'hungry stranger' philosophy. Her leadership ensures consistent service quality and community connection.
Questions
What makes your soups special?
Our soups are made daily from scratch using natural ingredients and no commercial starters, following family recipes developed by Jim Mikula.
Do you offer vegetarian or vegan options?
Yes, we provide extensive vegetarian options and several vegan choices across our menu to accommodate different dietary preferences.
What are your operating hours?
We're open Monday through Saturday from 7:00 AM to 7:00 PM with consistent hours year-round.
Can you accommodate catering orders?
Yes, we offer drop-off catering services featuring our signature soups, sandwiches, and baked goods for various events and gatherings.
Is there outdoor seating available?
We provide casual outdoor seating alongside air-conditioned indoor dining to accommodate different weather preferences.
How far are you from Lake Erie beaches?
Our Fredonia location sits just three miles from Lake Erie beaches and the Dunkirk Boardwalk, making us a convenient dining option.