Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
11 Years
experience
Handcrafted Pies & Fresh Baked Goods in Kansas City
Ashleigh's Bake Shop was founded in 2015 by Ashleigh and her father Bud, who began perfecting pie recipes together during a summer of experimentation. Our family-owned business operates from the historic Prydes Kitchen Store in Westport, Kansas City, where we craft all our pies using a secret all-butter crust recipe. With a commitment to quality, we bake fresh daily in small batches, using homemade fillings and avoiding pre-made ingredients. Our tiny kitchen, equipped with just one oven and one fridge, reflects our dedication to hands-on craftsmanship.

We prioritize customer relationships, offering special orders with 48-hour notice and maintaining transparency about our nut allergy limitations. Our team includes Ashleigh, Bud, and Lee Ann, who manage baking, packaging, and customer service. We take pride in our loyal customer base and our reputation for exceptional flavor and freshness.
Services
Handcrafted Pies Custom Special Orders Wedding Pies Fresh Quiches Cookies & Bars
Details
  • Year established: 2015
Highlights and features
  • We use a secret all-butter crust recipe perfected over 8 years.
  • All fillings are made from scratch with fresh ingredients daily.
  • Family-run operation with hands-on quality control from start to finish.
  • Special orders available with 48-hour notice for guaranteed availability.
  • Transparent nut allergy disclosure and ingredient sourcing practices.
Services
Handcrafted Pies
Our handcrafted pies feature a secret all-butter crust and homemade fillings made from fresh ingredients daily. Available in over 15 rotating flavors including seasonal specialties, all pies are baked to order in small batches. Customers can choose from fruit, cream, meringue, and chess varieties, with options for special dietary requests when possible.
Custom Special Orders
We offer custom special orders for whole pies with 48-hour notice to ensure availability. Customers can request specific flavors, dietary adaptations, and pickup times. Our team confirms all orders daily and provides updates to guarantee fresh, timely delivery of your requested selections.
Wedding Pies
Ashleighs provides wedding pies with tasting sessions for $25, offering up to 5 flavor samples. We deliver within the KC metro area for $25 or allow pickup for out-of-town events. Each unsliced pie serves approximately 8 guests, ensuring fresh presentation at your special event.
Fresh Quiches
Our daily-baked quiches feature flaky butter crusts and fresh ingredients like bacon, leek, and seasonal vegetables. Available in multiple varieties including vegetarian options, these savory pies reheat perfectly and serve as excellent breakfast or party dishes for any occasion.
Cookies & Bars
We craft classic cookies and bars using premium ingredients, including chocolate chip cookies, lemon shortbread, and pecan bars. Available for individual purchase or small batch orders with 48-hour notice, these treats complement any gathering or personal indulgence.
People
Ashleigh
Owner & Baker
Founder of Ashleigh's Bake Shop, Ashleigh creates all pie recipes and oversees daily baking operations with her father Bud. She manages special orders, wedding tastings, and customer relations while maintaining quality standards in their small-batch production process.
Bud
Co-Owner & Baker
Ashleigh's father Bud co-founded the bakery, perfecting pie fillings and crusts alongside her. He handles baking logistics, ingredient preparation, and quality control in their compact kitchen setup that maintains their signature freshness standards.
Lee Ann
Customer Service
Ashleigh's mother Lee Ann manages order coordination and customer communications, handling phone inquiries and packaging operations. She contributes to the family-run business's personalized service approach during weekend hours.
Questions
What are your regular business hours?
We operate Fridays and Saturdays from 10:00 AM to 5:00 PM or until sell-out. Special orders require 48-hour notice for guaranteed availability.
Do you offer nut-free options?
Due to our small kitchen and ingredient suppliers, we cannot guarantee nut-free products. Almond extract appears in some recipes, and cross-contamination risks exist.
Can I order custom pies for events?
Yes! We provide special orders for weddings and events with 48-hour notice. Wedding tastings cost $25 with delivery options available within the KC metro area.
What quiche varieties do you offer?
Our rotating quiche menu includes Bacon & Leek, Broccoli & Cheddar, Ham & Leek, Spinach & Bacon, and specialty options like Crab Pie with 1-week notice.
How should I store leftover pie?
We recommend consuming pies the day of purchase for optimal freshness. Refrigerate cream pies and consume within 2 days; fruit pies can be stored at room temperature for 1-2 days.