Business Details
11 Years
experience
Authentic Italian Dining in Olmsted Falls
We are Matteo's Casual Italian, a family-owned restaurant rooted in the Olmsted Falls community since 2015. Our team of four co-ownersCraig Allenbaugh, Deserai Satullo, Daniel Cliff, and Jessica Cliffbrings decades of combined culinary expertise and deep local ties to our operations. We specialize in authentic Italian cuisine inspired by the Abruzzo/Rome region, served in a welcoming environment designed for families and special occasions. Our commitment to quality extends to our catering services, private event hosting for up to 50 guests, and flexible menu options including vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free dishes. We maintain rigorous standards in food preparation and service, ensuring every guest experiences the warmth of Italian hospitality.With lunch service Tuesday through Saturday and dinner hours tailored to community needs, we strive to be both a daily gathering place and a destination for memorable celebrations. Our team's culinary school training and dedication to innovation keep our offerings fresh while honoring traditional techniques. We actively engage with local schools and community organizations, reflecting our belief that restaurants should serve as neighborhood anchors. Through transparent communication and attention to dietary needs, we aim to make every dining experience inclusive and enjoyable.
Services
Dining Room Service
Private Event Hosting
Catering Services
Online Ordering
Gift Card Sales
Details
- Year established: 2015
Highlights and features
- We offer 9 years of combined culinary expertise from our owner-operated team
- Our private event space accommodates up to 50 guests with full-service catering
- We provide dietary-friendly options including vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free menus
- Our team maintains direct communication channels for personalized event planning
- We operate transparent gift card policies with clear redemption terms
Services
Dining Room Service
Our main dining room offers family-friendly seating with traditional Italian decor. Guests enjoy lunch service Tuesday through Saturday starting at 11:30 AM and dinner hours tailored to community needs. The space features separate lounge and private dining areas for varied group sizes while maintaining consistent service standards across all seating options.
Private Event Hosting
Our upstairs private party room accommodates up to 50 guests for special occasions. The space includes full-service bar and buffet capabilities with customizable decor options. Professional staff handles all service aspects while event planners coordinate menu customization and timing logistics to match client visions for weddings, showers, and corporate events.
Catering Services
We provide off-site catering with flexible by-the-pan pricing and menu customization. Our team delivers house-made Italian dishes including dietary-friendly options to locations throughout Olmsted Falls. Full-service coordination includes menu planning, quantity calculations, and on-site service staff for events ranging from small gatherings to large celebrations.
Online Ordering
Our digital platform enables convenient ordering of menu items for pickup or delivery. The system maintains menu accuracy and pricing transparency while supporting special requests and dietary modifications. Online ordering operates during regular business hours with real-time order tracking capabilities for customer convenience.
Gift Card Sales
We offer gift cards redeemable for all dining and catering services with transparent redemption policies. Current gift card holders receive 50% value retention for pre-November 2024 purchases through our buy-back program. Physical cards can be redeemed in-person while digital gift certificates are available for online purchases.
People
Craig Allenbaugh
Co-Owner
Co-owner with 15+ years culinary experience, previously trained at Le Cordon Bleu. Active community member supporting local schools through restaurant initiatives. Brings operational expertise to daily management and menu development.
Deserai Satullo
Co-Owner
Co-owner focused on guest relations and event coordination. Culinary school graduate with specialization in Italian cuisine. Community advocate organizing local charity events through restaurant partnerships. Oversees staff training and service standards.
Daniel Cliff
Co-Owner
Co-owner managing financial operations and supply chain logistics. Culinary-trained professional with restaurant management background. Community leader serving on local business association boards. Ensures quality control across all menu offerings.
Jessica Cliff
Co-Owner
Co-owner specializing in marketing and digital operations. Culinary educator with food safety certification. Active parent-teacher association member leveraging restaurant platform for community outreach. Manages online presence and customer engagement strategies.
Questions
What gift card policy changes occurred in November 2024?
We implemented a 50% buy-back program for pre-November 2024 gift cards due to undisclosed liabilities from prior ownership. Present original cards in person for redemption at our Olmsted Falls location.
Do you offer catering services for large events?
Yes, our catering team serves events of all sizes with customizable menus. We provide by-the-pan pricing options and full-service staff for events up to 50 guests at our private space or your chosen location.
What private event options are available?
Our upstairs private room accommodates 45-50 seated guests with full bar service and buffet capabilities. The space features adjustable layouts for weddings, corporate events, and family celebrations with dedicated event coordinator support.
Can I order food online for pickup?
Yes, our online ordering system allows convenient pickup orders during regular business hours. The platform supports dietary modifications and special requests while maintaining real-time menu accuracy.
Are dietary-friendly options available?
We offer vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free menu alternatives across our lunch and dinner selections. Our chefs accommodate special dietary needs while maintaining authentic Italian flavor profiles in all modified dishes.
What are your lunch service hours?
Lunch service runs Tuesday through Saturday starting at 11:30 AM. Our lunch menu features abbreviated versions of dinner specialties with quicker service times for business professionals and local residents.
