Experience the Taste of Tradition!
At Rico's Pizzeria, we're passionate about serving the best pizza in Sarasota. With a passion for creating delicious, mouth-watering dishes, our founder Mark Riley opened our doors in 1999 with the goal of providing a unique and unbeatable dining experience. As a family-owned business, we take pride in making everything to order, using only the freshest ingredients and traditional cooking methods to ensure every bite is a delight.
Our Story
Our story began with a simple dream: to create the best pizza in Sarasota. With a passion for cooking and a commitment to quality, Mark Riley, our founder, set out to create a menu that would delight the senses and leave our customers coming back for more. From our hand-tossed pizza dough, made fresh daily, to our signature cheesecakes, baked in-house, every dish is a labor of love. We're proud to be a part of the Gulf Gate community, and we're dedicated to providing exceptional service and unparalleled flavor to every guest who walks through our doors.
Our Services
At Rico's Pizzeria, we offer a wide range of services to meet your dining needs. From dine-in to take-out, delivery, and catering, we've got you covered. Our menu features a variety of options, including vegetarian, gluten-free, and traditional favorites, all made to order and customizable to your taste. We're also happy to accommodate private events, parties, and corporate functions, with customizable menus and exceptional service. And don't forget to join our Rewards Program for exclusive offers and discounts!
Overall Experience
The reviews highlight a mix of positive and negative experiences at Rico's Pizza. While some customers had an excellent time, enjoying the food and service, others were disappointed with their orders and the treatment they received.
Food Quality
The food quality received mixed reviews. Some customers raved about the pizza, cheesecake, and other dishes, describing them as "fabulous, " "great, " and "superb." However, others were disappointed with the greasiness of their pizza, the lopsidedness of the toppings, and the burnt crust.
Service
The service also received mixed reviews. Some customers praised the friendly and attentive service, citing specific staff members who went above and beyond. However, others were disappointed with the unfriendly and unhelpful service they received, including issues with orders being incorrect or missing.
Atmosphere
The atmosphere of the restaurant was also mentioned in several reviews. While some customers enjoyed the cozy and intimate setting, others described it as a "hole in the wall" and small.
Be the first to review Rico's Pizzeria.
Write a Review
