Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
45 Years
experience
Your Daily Destination for Fresh Baked Goods in Aspen
Since 1981, we have been Aspen's premier destination for handcrafted baked goods, celebrated for our commitment to quality and tradition. Our cookies and muffins, baked daily since 1976, use only the finest ingredients to deliver exceptional flavor. Our homemade gelato, a local favorite year-round, combines artisanal techniques with innovative flavors. Our fresh-squeezed lemonade, rooted in a family recipe predating Gatorade, offers a refreshing experience unmatched by competitors. We prioritize creating memorable customer experiences through our dedication to excellence in every product we serve. Our menu features 9 cookie varieties, including gluten-free options, alongside seasonal specialties that reflect Aspen's dynamic character.

As a locally owned institution, we take pride in sourcing ingredients responsibly and supporting community partnerships. Our team of skilled bakers and baristas brings decades of collective experience to daily operations, ensuring consistency and quality. From early morning coffee to decadent desserts, we strive to be Aspen's gathering place for fresh, flavorful offerings. Our 24-hour online ordering system and gift card program provide convenient access to our full product range for locals and visitors alike.
Services
Cookies Muffins Gelato Coffee Lemonade Breakfast Burritos Brownies Croissants Desserts Gift Cards
Details
  • Year established: 1981
Highlights and features
  • Locally owned and operated since 1981 with deep community roots
  • Homemade gelato made using traditional Italian techniques
  • Cookies baked daily from scratch since 1976
  • 9 varieties of cookies including gluten-free options
  • Family recipe fresh-squeezed lemonade unavailable elsewhere
What people say
Famous cookies Homemade gelato Fresh ingredients Aspen institution Great experience
Services
Cookies
Our signature cookies have been baked daily from scratch since 1976 using premium ingredients. We offer 9 varieties including classic chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, and gluten-free options. Each batch maintains the same quality and flavor that made us famous, with seasonal specials like pumpkin nut and zucchini nut available during specific months.
Gelato
Homemade gelato is crafted using traditional Italian methods with natural ingredients. Our rotating selection includes 20+ flavors like Alpine Strawberry, Salted Caramel, and Espresso Robusto. Seasonal specialties and classic options remain popular year-round, with sorbetto alternatives available for dairy-free preferences.
Coffee
We serve specialty coffee drinks made with freshly roasted beans and expert barista techniques. Menu includes drip coffee, cold brew, lattes, and unique creations like the Paradise Latte. Hot and iced tea options, fresh-squeezed lemonade, and seasonal specials like pumpkin spice latte complement our coffee offerings.
Muffins
Daily baked muffins feature both traditional and innovative flavors including banana nut, lemon poppyseed, and gluten-free morning glory. Our cinnamon roll and spinach quiche muffins provide savory alternatives, while seasonal fruit varieties reflect local availability throughout the year.
Breakfast Burritos
Freshly prepared breakfast burritos combine high-quality ingredients in a flour tortilla wrap. Options include bacon or spinach fillings with eggs, green chili, cheddar cheese, potatoes, and black beans. Each burrito provides a hearty meal option for customers seeking substantial morning fare.
Questions
What are Paradise Bakery's operating hours?
We're open daily from 6:30 AM to 9:00 PM for in-store purchases and order pickups.
Do you offer gluten-free options?
Yes, we provide 9 gluten-free cookie varieties and several gluten-free muffin options available daily.
Can I order ahead for pickup?
Yes, our 24-hour online ordering system allows advance orders for convenient pickup at your preferred time.
What makes your lemonade special?
Our signature lemonade follows a family recipe from before Gatorade, featuring a unique process that creates full-bodied, ice-cold refreshment.
Are gift cards available?
Yes, we offer physical and digital gift cards in any denomination for purchase through our website or in-store.
Do you have seasonal menu items?
Yes, we rotate seasonal specialties like pumpkin nut cookies in fall and blood orange sorbetto in winter.