Business Details
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Ohio
At Hitchings Insurance, we exist to make it easier for people to succeed by prioritizing personalized service over policies. Our team of experienced professionals takes the time to understand your unique needs, whether you're an individual, family, or business owner. We offer tailored insurance solutions across home, auto, health, farm, and commercial sectors, leveraging relationships with 20+ insurers to secure competitive rates. Our commitment to transparency ensures you receive clear explanations of coverage options without sales pitches.With decades of combined experience and a focus on community, we actively listen to clients and adapt coverage as their lives evolve. Our approach extends beyond transactionswe build lasting relationships while supporting local organizations and youth initiatives. This philosophy has earned us 366+ five-star reviews, reflecting our dedication to exceptional service and customer satisfaction.
Services
Home Insurance
Auto Insurance
Health Insurance
Farm Insurance
Commercial Insurance
Highlights and features
- We offer personalized insurance consultations via phone, email, or video chat
- We review 20+ insurers to find your best rate and coverage combination
- 366+ five-star reviews validate our customer-centric approach
- Our team provides proactive coverage recommendations based on your circumstances
- We explain complex insurance concepts in simple, accessible language
What people say
Excellent customer service
Proactive coverage recommendations
Huge savings achieved
Knowledgeable professionals
Personalized attention
Services
Home Insurance
Our home insurance protects Ohio and Michigan homeowners against property damage, liability claims, and living expense disruptions. We tailor policies for standard homes, barndominiums, townhouses, and rental properties while identifying coverage gaps. Our experts explain replacement cost vs actual value differences and ensure proper dwelling, garage, and personal property protection.
Auto Insurance
We provide Ohio-compliant auto insurance covering liability, collision, and comprehensive protection for cars, trucks, SUVs, and classic vehicles. Our team helps optimize coverage through bundling discounts, deductible adjustments, and umbrella policy options while explaining state-mandated minimum requirements versus recommended enhanced protection.
Farm Insurance
Our farm insurance specialists protect Ohio agricultural operations with customized policies covering equipment, livestock, buildings, and liability. We address unique risks like crop damage, machinery breakdowns, and seasonal variations while offering blanket coverage options. Our team includes farming professionals who understand both small family farms and large commercial operations.
Commercial Insurance
We safeguard Ohio businesses with comprehensive commercial insurance covering liability, property damage, cyber threats, and employee benefits. Our specialists assess industry-specific risks for restaurants, contractors, manufacturers, and service providers while offering umbrella policies for enhanced protection beyond standard limits.
Health Insurance
Our health insurance advisors help Ohio individuals and employers navigate Medicare, marketplace plans, and group coverage options. We explain plan differences, prescription drug coverage, and supplemental insurance while providing personalized recommendations for families, retirees, and business owners seeking affordable healthcare solutions.
People
Brock Colman
Insurance Professional
Specializing in health, farm, and personal lines insurance since 2015, Brock provides tailored coverage solutions. He graduated from Owens Community College and focuses on educating clients through social media as 'The Insurance Guy'.
Dominic Frey
Insurance Professional
With expertise in commercial and farm insurance, Dominic holds an MBA from Heidelberg University. He specializes in risk assessment and has received recognition for his video-based policy explanations that simplify complex insurance concepts for clients.
Grace George
Insurance Professional
Licensed in group health and Medicare plans, Grace tailors employee benefits packages to business needs. She combines agency support experience with personalized client consultations, maintaining connections to Ohio's agricultural community through family farm involvement.
Ryan Pessell
President
Leading the agency since 2016, Ryan specializes in commercial and farm insurance. With claims experience from The Hartford, he focuses on relationship-building and graduated from Tiffin University with expertise in managing complex business insurance needs.
Kari Colman
Vice President
Responsible for brand strategy and operations, Kari enhances customer experiences through technology improvements. A Bowling Green State University graduate, she manages marketing initiatives while maintaining focus on controllable agency processes.
Questions
What types of insurance does Hitchings Insurance offer?
We provide home, auto, health, farm, and commercial insurance with specialized options including umbrella policies, employee benefits, and agricultural coverage.
Do you serve both individuals and businesses?
Yes, we offer personal insurance for individuals and families plus commercial coverage for businesses of all sizes across multiple industries.
How do you help clients save money?
We review 20+ insurers to find competitive rates, identify bundling opportunities, and recommend deductible adjustments while maintaining appropriate coverage levels.
Are your agents licensed professionals?
All our insurance professionals maintain active licenses with specialized expertise in their respective fields including farm insurance, commercial risk assessment, and healthcare coverage.
How quickly can I get insurance coverage?
We typically provide quotes within minutes and can often finalize coverage the same day through our streamlined consultation process via phone, email, or video chat.
Do you offer online policy management tools?
While we prioritize personal service, we provide digital tools for policy updates, ID card requests, and certificate of insurance generation through our secure online portal.
Videos
