Business Details
16 Years
experience
Vintage Engagement Rings & Custom Jewelry in NYC
Founded in 2010 by fifth-generation jeweler Jared Klusner and Alisa Klusner, Erstwhile Jewelry specializes in curating and crafting vintage engagement rings, wedding bands, and antique jewelry. Our expertise lies in sourcing rare antique diamonds from the Victorian, Edwardian, and Art Deco eras, reimagining them in handcrafted designs that honor historical craftsmanship. With a heritage rooted in a family legacy dating back to 1887, we combine deep industry knowledge with a passion for preserving timeless beauty.Our New York City showroom offers clients an intimate experience to explore our collection, while our virtual services cater to a global clientele. We are committed to transparency, quality, and personalized service, ensuring each piece tells a unique story of enduring love and artistry.
Services
Vintage Engagement Rings
Custom Design Service
Wedding Bands
Cocktail Rings
Antique Jewelry Appraisal
Ring Sizing
Virtual Consultations
Showroom Appointments
International Shipping
Financing Options
Details
- Year established: 2010
Highlights and features
- We offer fifth-generation expertise in antique jewelry craftsmanship.
- Our team sources museum-quality diamonds with documented historical provenance.
- We provide personalized virtual consultations for global clientele.
- Our NYC showroom features an intimate setting for hands-on expertise.
- We specialize in recreating archive pieces no longer available on the market.
What people say
Rare antique pieces
Expert guidance
Unique designs
Personalized service
Beautiful craftsmanship
Services
Vintage Engagement Rings
Curated collection of one-of-a-kind engagement rings from the Victorian, Edwardian, and Art Deco eras. Each piece features rare antique diamonds and period-specific craftsmanship. Ideal for clients seeking historically significant jewelry with unique character and provenance.
Custom Design Service
Collaborative process creating personalized engagement rings using antique diamonds and handcrafted settings. Clients work directly with designers to modify existing pieces or develop new concepts. Combines old-world techniques with modern customization preferences.
Wedding Bands
Handcrafted wedding bands featuring antique diamonds and precious metals. Designs range from simple classic styles to intricate vintage-inspired patterns. Available in gold, platinum, and white gold options for both men and women.
Cocktail Rings
Collection of vintage cocktail rings showcasing bold designs from the 1920s-1970s. Features rare gemstones and distinctive settings that reflect historical artistic movements. Perfect for collectors seeking wearable art pieces with historical significance.
Antique Jewelry Appraisal
Professional appraisal services for vintage jewelry conducted by industry experts. Provides detailed documentation of authenticity, quality, and market value. Available for insurance purposes or pre-purchase verification of antique pieces.
People
Jared Klusner
Founder & Fifth-Generation Jeweler
Fifth-generation jeweler with expertise in antique diamonds and historical jewelry. Sourced museum-quality pieces for major houses before founding Erstwhile Jewelry. Combines family legacy with modern craftsmanship in curating vintage collections.
Alisa Klusner
Co-Founder
Fashion-trained co-founder bringing design expertise to Erstwhile Jewelry's collections. Collaborates on aesthetic direction and client experience. Balances creative vision with practical business operations in vintage jewelry curation.
Questions
What makes Erstwhile's vintage rings unique?
Our rings feature rare antique diamonds from the 1880s-1930s with historical provenance. Each piece combines exceptional craftsmanship with documented heritage.
Can I customize an existing vintage design?
Yes, we offer modifications to existing pieces or complete custom designs using antique diamonds and period-appropriate techniques.
Do you provide international shipping?
We ship worldwide via insured FedEx or UPS. International customers pay $175 shipping plus applicable duties and taxes.
What payment options are available?
We accept credit cards, wire transfers, PayPal, and checks. Financing through Affirm available for purchases up to $17,500.
Can you resize vintage rings?
Most rings can be resized. First resizing is complimentary with purchase. Additional resizes cost $80-$100 depending on metal type.
Do you sell newly made vintage-style jewelry?
We specialize in authentic antique pieces and handcrafted reproductions using traditional techniques rather than mass-produced vintage-inspired designs.
