At Mama Mia Pie & Pasta, we are proud to offer a warm and inviting atmosphere, where everyone is treated like family. Our goal is to provide exceptional service, delicious food, and a welcoming environment for our guests. We take great pride in selecting only the finest ingredients to prepare our traditional Italian Roma-style meals and all of our own sauces, doughs, meatballs, and other menu items from scratch.
Our Story
Mama Mia Pie & Pasta is a family-owned and operated restaurant located in the heart of Elkins, WV. Our story began with a passion for traditional Italian cuisine and a desire to share that passion with our community. Our family has been cooking with love for generations, and we bring that love to every dish that leaves our kitchen. We strive to create an experience that is truly unforgettable, with dishes that are made fresh daily, using the finest local and imported ingredients.
Our Menu
Our menu is a reflection of our commitment to traditional Italian cuisine, with dishes that are crafted with care and served with a smile. From our homemade pasta to our freshly baked bread, we combine old-world flavors with modern twists to create a unique dining experience. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty pasta dish, a flavorful pizza, or a comforting sub, we have something for everyone on our menu.
Specials and Promotions
We are always looking for ways to make your dining experience even more enjoyable. That's why we offer a variety of specials and promotions throughout the week. From our daily lunch specials to our dinner for four options, we have something to suit every taste and budget. Be sure to check our website for the latest deals and promotions.
Catering and Take-Out
We understand that sometimes you can't make it to our restaurant, which is why we offer catering and take-out options. Whether you're planning a party, a meeting, or just need a quick dinner at home, we can help. Our menu is available for take-out, and we also offer catering options for larger groups and events. Contact us to learn more about our catering and take-out services.
Contact Us
We're always happy to hear from our customers and answer any questions you may have. Whether you're looking for information about our menu, hours of operation, or just want to say hello, we're here to help. Please don't hesitate to reach out to us at 304-637-5858 or visit our website for more information.
Overview of Reviews
The reviews are overwhelmingly positive, with most reviewers giving 5-star ratings and praising the restaurant's food, service, and atmosphere.
Food Quality
The food at the restaurant is a major highlight, with many reviewers raving about the delicious and tender meatballs, phenomenal pasta dishes, and flavorful sauces. The portions are also mentioned as being generous, with some reviewers warning not to order too much food.
Service
The service at the restaurant is also highly praised, with many reviewers complimenting the friendly, polite, and attentive staff. One reviewer did mention that their server was new and didn't check on their table often, but this is an isolated incident.
Atmosphere
The atmosphere of the restaurant is described as quaint, cozy, and welcoming, with some reviewers mentioning the decor as not being over-the-top.
Parking
One reviewer mentioned that finding parking can be somewhat difficult, but there is free street parking available.

Be the first to review Mama Mia Pie & Pasta.
Write a Review