Focused on Service. Dedicated to Excellence.
At Monteleone & Siegel, PLLC, we pride ourselves on providing exceptional legal services to our clients. Our attorneys, Andrew A. Monteleone and Jarad L. Siegel, have over 25 years of combined experience in personal injury and criminal defense. With a deep understanding of the legal system and a commitment to excellence, we strive to deliver the best possible outcomes for our clients.
Our Practice Areas
Our law firm focuses on several key practice areas, including:
Personal Injury
- Car accident litigation
- Construction accidents
- Premises liability (slip/trip and fall)
- Medical malpractice
- Nursing home negligence
Criminal Defense
- Misdemeanor and felony charges
- Attempted murder trials
- Auto accident litigation
- Traffic violations
- Workers' compensation
Appellate Law
- Briefing and arguing motions at the trial and appellate levels
- Complex motion and appellate practice
- Labor law, medical malpractice, premises liability, and general negligence
Traffic Violations
- Defense against traffic violations
- Representing clients in traffic court
Workers' Compensation
- Claim preparation and representation
- Wages and medical benefits
Our Attorneys
Andrew A. Monteleone graduated from Fordham University School of Law in 1999. He worked as an Assistant District Attorney in the Nassau County District Attorney's Office, prosecuting numerous misdemeanor and felony charges. After leaving the prosecutor's office, Mr. Monteleone worked for a civil litigation firm in New York City, defending construction companies in construction accident lawsuits. He has since established a successful law practice, handling numerous personal injury matters resulting in favorable settlements for his clients and successfully defending criminal clients.
Jarad L. Siegel is a partner with Monteleone & Siegel, PLLC. Mr. Siegel has briefed and argued dozens of motions and appeals at the trial and appellate levels. His practice is primarily devoted to complex motion and appellate practice, covering a range of personal injury-related issues. Mr. Siegel's well-written briefs have received praise from state and federal judges.
Our Mission
At Monteleone & Siegel, PLLC, our mission is to provide personalized attention and exceptional legal services to our clients. We understand the importance of attention to detail and the need for effective communication in navigating the complex legal system. Our goal is to deliver the best possible outcomes for our clients while maintaining a commitment to excellence and integrity.
Our History
Monteleone & Siegel, PLLC was founded in January 2016, when Andrew A. Monteleone merged his firm with the Law Office of Jarad Siegel. The firm is headquartered in Mineola, New York, and serves clients throughout the state and federal courts of New York.
Summary of Reviews
General Impressions
The reviews are predominantly positive, with reviewers praising the law firm's professionalism, expertise, and dedication to their clients.
Positive Experiences
Many reviewers have had excellent experiences with the law firm, citing the attorneys' professionalism, courtesy, and expertise. They appreciate the firm's prompt and efficient communication, thoroughness, and ability to provide comfort and strength during difficult times. Some reviewers have also expressed gratitude for the firm's ability to secure favorable outcomes in their cases.
Negative Experience
One reviewer had a negative experience with the law firm, citing that the attorney dropped their case without sufficient explanation and did not thoroughly investigate the incident. This reviewer felt that the attorney was not willing to fight for their case and instead looked for quick settlements.
Common Themes
Some common themes among the positive reviews include:
- Professionalism and courtesy: Reviewers praise the attorneys' professional demeanor and courteous treatment.
- Expertise and knowledge: Reviewers appreciate the attorneys' expertise and knowledge in their respective fields.
- Communication and responsiveness: Reviewers value the firm's prompt and efficient communication, as well as their responsiveness to clients' needs.

Be the first to review Monteleone & Siegel.
Write a Review