Experience the authentic flavors of Mexico in the heart of Key West
Located in the heart of Key West, Florida, Old Town Mexican Cafe is a culinary haven that has been delighting locals and visitors alike with its innovative take on Southwest and authentic Mexican cuisine since 1999. Our award-winning menu, crafted by Chef Gail Brockway, offers a departure from the typical Tex-Mex fare, providing a unique and memorable dining experience.
Our Story
As a family-owned and operated restaurant, we are committed to serving the highest-quality dishes made with only the freshest ingredients. Our menu is a reflection of our passion for Mexican cuisine, our commitment to health-conscious dining, and our unwavering belief that every guest deserves an extraordinary experience.
Our Vision
Our core values are built on three fundamental principles:
Dedication to Southwestern Cuisine
Chef Gail Brockway's passion for Mexican cuisine is at the heart of our vision. Every dish is crafted with vibrant flavors, offering a celebration of health and deliciousness on every plate.
Exceptional Service
From the moment you step through our doors, our team is dedicated to ensuring your time with us is nothing short of extraordinary. We believe in treating everyone in our company with equal respect, recognizing the unique worth each individual brings to our culinary family.
Authentic Tequila Bar
Home to over 200 meticulously curated tequila selections, our bar is a haven for tequila enthusiasts and novices alike. Step into our unique haven and savor the flavors of Mexico like never before, right here in Key West.
Mouthwatering Menu Options
Our menu is designed to tantalize your taste buds with its wide range of options. From classic favorites to creative twists, our dishes are crafted to delight both vegetarians and meat-lovers alike. Whether you're in the mood for something spicy or looking for something new and exciting, our menu is sure to please.
Lively Atmosphere
Step into our inviting space and be transported to a world where the vibrant flavors of Sante Fe-inspired dishes blend seamlessly with the tropical charm of Key West. Our prime location on historic Duval Street offers a front-row seat for some of the best people-watching in Key West. And when you need a break from the tropical heat, our cool air-conditioned dining area offers the perfect respite.
Special Offers
Join us for Happy Hour, where you can enjoy half-price apps, drinks, and cheers from 4-6 PM every day. Always a party atmosphere, our Happy Hour is the perfect excuse to gather with friends and make some unforgettable memories.
Chef's Corner
Stay ahead of the game with our expert guidance. Whether you're looking to elevate your taco game or master the art of guacamole, our Chef's Corner is the go-to spot for insider tips and tricks from our culinary team.
News & Events
Stay connected to our culinary journey by following us on social media. From exclusive promotions to behind-the-scenes peeks, our social media pages offer a glimpse into the world of Old Town Mexican Cafe.
Overall Experience
The reviews for this Mexican restaurant are mixed, with a range of ratings from 1 to 5 stars. While some customers had a positive experience, others were unhappy with the food and service.
Food
The quality of the food varies significantly among reviewers. Some complain about dry and chewy cheese and steak, while others rave about the flavorful and delicious cuisine. The prices are also a point of contention, with some customers feeling that the food is overpriced. On the other hand, some reviewers enjoy their meals and find the portions to be generous.
Service
The service at the restaurant seems to be inconsistent. Some reviewers report excellent service, with friendly and attentive waitstaff, while others experience long wait times and unresponsive servers. Additionally, some customers complain about the high gratuity charge, which is added to the bill.
Atmosphere
The atmosphere of the restaurant is a highlight for many reviewers, with some praising the unique decor and cozy atmosphere. However, others are put off by the plastic chairs and trash bag pendants.
Be the first to review Old Town Mexican Cafe.
Write a Review
