Business Details
27 Years
experience
Authentic Mexican Cuisine & Tequila Bar in Key West
Since 1999, Old Town Mexican Cafe has been a culinary cornerstone in Key West, Florida, redefining authentic Mexican cuisine through innovative dishes and a vibrant tequila bar. Under Chef Gail Brockway's expertise, we blend Sante Fe-inspired flavors with tropical Key West charm, offering a menu that transcends typical Tex-Mex fare. Our tequila bar showcases over 200 curated selections, inviting guests to explore agave spirits' nuanced diversity. Committed to inclusivity, we provide vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options while maintaining a dedication to health-conscious dining. Located on historic Duval Street, our air-conditioned dining area and lively patio offer prime people-watching opportunities and a respite from Florida's heat.Our team prioritizes exceptional service, ensuring every guest experiences the warmth of Mexican hospitality. With decades of culinary passion, we celebrate Mexico's cultural heritage through dishes that honor tradition while embracing creativity. Our establishment remains a community fixture, serving locals and visitors alike with equal respect and dedication to quality. From Taco Tuesday specials to award-winning entrees, we strive to create memorable dining experiences rooted in authenticity and excellence.
Services
Mexican Cuisine
Tequila Bar
Happy Hour
Catering Services
Dietary Options
Details
- Year established: 1999
Highlights and features
- We offer over 200 curated tequila selections in Key West's premier agave bar
- Our menu features Sante Fe-inspired Mexican cuisine since 1999
- We provide vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options with every dish
- Our team maintains decades of culinary expertise in Mexican gastronomy
- We operate in a historic Duval Street location with tropical ambiance
What people say
Fantastic margaritas
Delicious tacos
Lovely place
No complaints
Amazing fajitas
Services
Mexican Cuisine
Our kitchen crafts innovative Mexican dishes using traditional techniques and fresh ingredients. Chef Gail Brockway's menu blends Sante Fe flavors with tropical influences, offering everything from $4 tacos on Tuesdays to premium fajitas. Each plate showcases Mexico's regional diversity while maintaining authentic culinary heritage.
Tequila Bar
Home to Key West's largest tequila collection, our bar features over 200 curated agave spirits. From premium reposados to rare mezcals, our selection offers tasting journeys through Mexico's tequila regions. Knowledgeable staff guide guests through flavor profiles and pairing options with our Mexican cuisine.
Happy Hour
Enjoy daily happy hour from 4-6 PM with half-price appetizers, discounted well drinks, and $2 off draft beers. Our lively patio setting surrounded by tropical greenery creates the perfect atmosphere for after-work relaxation or pre-dinner socializing in historic Key West.
Catering Services
We provide authentic Mexican catering for private events and celebrations. Our menu options feature traditional dishes adapted for large groups, with full service including setup, service staff, and themed decorations that bring Mexico's vibrant culture to your special occasion.
Dietary Options
Our menu includes carefully crafted vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free alternatives without compromising authentic Mexican flavors. Each dietary option maintains traditional preparation methods while substituting ingredients to accommodate modern dietary needs and preferences.
People
Gail Brockway
Chef
Award-winning Chef Gail Brockway has led Old Town Mexican Cafe since 1999, creating innovative Mexican cuisine that blends Sante Fe traditions with tropical influences. Her culinary vision emphasizes authentic flavors and quality ingredients.
Questions
What makes your Mexican cuisine authentic?
Our menu features traditional Mexican dishes prepared using authentic techniques and ingredients, developed under Chef Gail Brockway's expertise in regional Mexican gastronomy.
Do you offer vegetarian/vegan options?
Yes, we provide carefully crafted vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free alternatives that maintain authentic Mexican flavors through traditional preparation methods.
What tequila selection can guests expect?
Our tequila bar features over 200 curated agave spirits including premium reposados, añejos, and rare mezcals from various Mexican regions.
Are there daily specials available?
Yes, we offer daily happy hour from 4-6 PM with half-price appetizers, discounted drinks, and $2 off draft beers, plus $4 tacos every Tuesday.
What's your location significance?
Located on historic Duval Street, we offer prime people-watching opportunities and easy access to Key West's main attractions while serving authentic Mexican cuisine.
