Choose Local. Choose Independent. Choose Auto Insurance Plus+.
At Auto Insurance Plus+, we are passionate about providing top-notch insurance services to the people of Clearwater and surrounding areas. As an independent insurance agency, we take pride in our ability to offer personalized solutions tailored to the unique needs of each client. With over 25 years of experience, we have built a reputation for exceptional customer service, competitive rates, and unparalleled expertise in the insurance industry.
Our Mission
Our mission is to provide comprehensive insurance solutions that cater to the diverse needs of our clients. We strive to create long-term relationships built on trust, reliability, and integrity. As an independent agency, we work for you, not the insurance carriers, ensuring that you receive the best possible coverage at an affordable price. Our team of experienced agents is dedicated to providing exceptional customer service, ensuring that you feel informed, confident, and protected.
Our Services
At Auto Insurance Plus+, we offer a wide range of insurance services, including:
- Auto Insurance: Comprehensive coverage options for vehicles, motorcycles, classic cars, boats, and watercraft
- Home Insurance: Affordable and comprehensive coverage for homeowners, renters, condo owners, landlords, and flood insurance
- Business Insurance: Customized policies for business owners, commercial property, commercial umbrella, general liability, and workers' compensation
- Life Insurance: Personalized life insurance planning and health insurance solutions
- Specialty Insurance: Coverage options for motorsport, ATV, RV, and motorhome owners
Our experienced agents will work closely with you to understand your unique needs and provide personalized recommendations for the most suitable insurance policies. We proudly represent a range of reputable insurance companies, ensuring that you have access to the best coverage options available.
Why Choose Us?
As an independent insurance agency, we offer a unique advantage:
- Unbiased advice: We work for you, not the insurance carriers, ensuring that you receive impartial guidance and recommendations.
- Personalized service: Our experienced agents take the time to understand your unique needs and provide tailored solutions.
- Competitive rates: We shop the market to find the best rates and coverage options for you.
- Convenience: We offer online quote requests, phone, and in-person consultations to fit your busy schedule.
Get in Touch
Ready to explore your insurance options? Fill out our online quote request form or call us at 727-446-9116 to speak with one of our experienced agents. We look forward to serving you!
Overall Experience
The majority of reviewers had a highly positive experience with Auto Insurance Plus, praising the excellent customer service, knowledgeable staff, and competitive rates.
Customer Service
Many reviewers commended Lesley and the staff for going above and beyond to meet their insurance needs. They were described as friendly, helpful, and willing to take the time to answer questions and address concerns.
Rates and Pricing
Several reviewers mentioned that they were able to get better rates with Auto Insurance Plus compared to other providers. The staff was able to find discounts and offer personalized solutions to meet their clients' needs.
Personalized Service
Reviewers appreciated the personal attention and small-agency feel of Auto Insurance Plus. They felt valued as clients and enjoyed the stress-free environment.
Negative Experiences
However, two reviewers had negative experiences, citing poor customer service, unprofessional behavior, and a focus on making money rather than providing good service.

Be the first to review Auto Insurance Plus.
Write a Review