Business Details
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Springfield, MO
Fortner Insurance is a locally owned, family-run insurance agency based in Springfield, Missouri, serving churches, businesses, and families across the state. With over 200 years of combined experience, our team prioritizes personalized service, transparent communication, and tailored coverage solutions. As a trusted Brotherhood Mutual partner, we specialize in church, camp, and business insurance, leveraging relationships with carriers like Liberty Mutual and Acuity to provide competitive options. Our co-owners, Anthony and Nell Gillen, ensure every client receives direct attention and practical guidance, whether through in-person consultations, phone support, or our self-service portal.We emphasize risk management resources, including church safety checklists and cyber liability protection, to help clients safeguard their assets and missions. Client testimonials highlight our commitment to exceptional service, with one noting our ability to research complex questions and recommend cost-effective solutions. Our statewide reach extends from St. Louis to Branson, ensuring Missouri residents and organizations receive coverage aligned with their unique needs.
Services
Business Insurance
Camp Insurance
Employee Benefits
Life Insurance
Medicare
Personal Insurance
Homeowners Insurance
Auto Insurance
Renters Insurance
Condo Insurance
Highlights and features
- We have over 200 years of combined experience in insurance.
- We are a trusted Brotherhood Mutual partner for church insurance.
- We offer flexible service options including in-person, phone, and self-service portal.
- Our team works with respected carriers like Brotherhood Mutual, Liberty Mutual, and Acuity.
- We provide personalized attention to Missouri clients across the state.
Associations and certifications
- Brotherhood Mutual Partner
What people say
Excellent customer service
Personalized attention
Trusted Brotherhood Mutual partner
Flexible service options
Respected carriers
Services
Business Insurance
Business Insurance protects Missouri organizations against risks like property damage, liability claims, and operational disruptions. We offer general liability, workers' compensation, and commercial auto policies tailored to industries ranging from nonprofits to construction. Our clients benefit from partnerships with carriers like Brotherhood Mutual and Liberty Mutual, ensuring competitive rates and comprehensive protection for businesses in Joplin, Branson, and beyond.
Camp Insurance
Camp Insurance provides specialized protection for Christian ministries and outdoor programs in Missouri. Policies include property coverage for cabins, liability for campers, and cyber liability for online registration systems. As a Brotherhood Mutual partner, we address unique risks like waterfront activities and youth protection, serving camps in the Ozarks and statewide with tailored solutions.
Church Insurance
Church Insurance safeguards Missouri faith communities with property, liability, and vehicle coverage. We address risks specific to churches, including pastoral counseling liability and mission trip protection. Our expertise as a Brotherhood Mutual partner ensures policies align with the needs of urban and rural congregations, from St. Louis to Cape Girardeau.
Personal Insurance
Personal Insurance offers Missouri families protection for homes, vehicles, and assets. We provide homeowners, auto, and umbrella policies tailored to local needs, including flood insurance for riverfront properties. Bundling options and partnerships with top carriers ensure affordable, comprehensive coverage for Springfield residents and surrounding communities.
Employee Benefits
Employee Benefits help Missouri employers design competitive health, dental, and life insurance packages. We assist businesses in navigating group plans that attract talent and support workforce well-being, leveraging relationships with carriers to find cost-effective solutions for small and mid-sized companies.
People
Anthony Gillen
Co-Owner
Anthony Gillen co-leads Fortner Insurance with a focus on personalized service and practical insurance solutions. He emphasizes building long-term client relationships and ensuring coverage aligns with Missourians' unique needs.
Nell Gillen
Co-Owner
Nell Gillen brings expertise in risk management and client communication to Fortner Insurance. She works closely with churches and businesses to provide tailored insurance strategies and maintain a client-centric approach.
Questions
What types of insurance does Fortner Insurance Services offer?
We provide business, camp, church, personal, and employee benefits insurance, including specialized coverage for Missouri churches and nonprofits.
How is Fortner Insurance different from other agencies?
We combine over 200 years of combined experience, local expertise, and partnerships with carriers like Brotherhood Mutual to offer personalized, faith-aligned solutions.
Can I file an insurance claim online?
Yes, visit our claims page for carrier contact info and next steps, or use our InsureLink portal for 24/7 account access.
Do you serve clients outside Springfield, Missouri?
Yes, we work with clients statewide, including St. Louis, Kansas City, Joplin, and Branson, offering in-person or remote support.
What risk management resources do you provide?
We offer church risk management checklists, cyber liability guidance, and safety resources for camps and schools.
