Your Path to the Perfect Home or Property, Every Step of the Way
A Legacy of Expertise & Client Focus on the North Fork
McCarthy Real Estate is a trusted name in the North Fork real estate market, renowned for its unparalleled expertise, personalized service, and unwavering integrity. Founded by Thomas and Susan McCarthy, the brokerage has become synonymous with success, consistently guiding clients through every step of their real estate journey.
Experienced Professionals at Your Service
Our team of experienced and certified agents boasts deep knowledge of the local market, enabling them to provide tailored guidance and innovative strategies to both buyers and sellers. We believe in a collaborative approach, working closely with you to understand your unique needs and aspirations.
Tailored Solutions for Every Client
Whether you're a first-time homebuyer or experienced investor, McCarthy Real Estate offers comprehensive services designed to meet your specific requirements. Our comprehensive marketing plans for sellers ensure your property reaches the right audience, while our detailed market analysis and negotiations empower buyers to secure their dream homes.
Our Commitment to the Community
Beyond just facilitating transactions, McCarthy Real Estate is deeply invested in the North Fork community. Thomas and Susan actively support land preservation, intelligent development, and civic participation, demonstrating their deep commitment to the future of the region.
Our Services Include
- Buying:
- Personalized home searches
- Market analysis and valuation
- Negotiation assistance
- Guidance through the entire closing process
- Selling:
- Comprehensive marketing campaigns
- Drone & video showcasing your property
- Open houses and private showings
- Competitive pricing strategies
- Additional Services:
- Mortgage calculators and financing options
- Buyer and seller representation
- Home evaluation and market analysis
- Connections to trusted local professionals
Overall Review Analysis
The reviews of McCarthy Real Estate are mixed, with both positive and negative comments.
Negative Comments
Lack of Professionalism and Quality
Some reviewers have expressed dissatisfaction with the agency's professionalism and quality of service. They have accused Tom McCarthy of being unresponsive, lazy, and only catering to wealthy clients, leaving common folk without assistance. Additionally, there are allegations of embezzlement and misappropriation of commissions, which raises serious concerns.
Positive Comments
Excellent Service and Local Market Knowledge
On the other hand, many reviewers have praised McCarthy Real Estate for their exceptional service, local market knowledge, and family-friendly staff. They have been commended for making the home-buying process smooth and fluid, with some clients considering Tom McCarthy a friend.

Be the first to review Thomas J McCarthy Real Estate.
Write a Review