Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
35 Years
experience
Experienced Legal Representation in Athens, Georgia
Based in Athens, Georgia, McArthur & McArthur has built a reputation for delivering exceptional legal representation across criminal law, divorce and family law, business litigation, real estate disputes, and personal injury cases. Our firm intentionally maintains a small size to ensure personalized service and flexible billing arrangements, enabling cost-effective solutions for our clients. With decades of combined legal experience, we prioritize understanding client goals to provide informed guidance on negotiation strategies, trial approaches, and alternative dispute resolution.

Our attorneys specialize in DUI defense, drug offenses, white-collar crimes, and underage possession of alcohol cases, particularly for University of Georgia students. We combine courtroom excellence with a commitment to confidentiality and proactive legal strategies to protect clients' rights and reputations.
Services
DUI Defense Criminal Defense Drug Offenses Divorce Personal Injury Business Litigation Probation Violations Estate Planning Intellectual Property
Details
  • Year established: 1991
Highlights and features
  • We offer 35+ years of courtroom experience in state and federal cases.
  • Our small firm structure ensures personalized attention and flexible billing.
  • Specialized defense for University of Georgia students facing underage charges.
  • Proven success in complex litigation with millions recovered in verdicts/settlements.
  • Attorneys maintain active community and professional leadership roles.
Services
DUI Defense
Our DUI defense practice focuses on protecting clients' rights through strategic representation in license suspension hearings and criminal proceedings. We challenge evidence, negotiate reduced charges, and leverage trial experience to secure dismissals. Clients benefit from our deep understanding of Georgia's DUI laws and local court procedures.
Criminal Defense
We defend clients facing state and federal criminal charges including drug crimes, white-collar offenses, and violent crimes. Our approach combines early intervention to prevent charges, plea negotiation expertise, and trial-ready advocacy. We prioritize minimizing long-term consequences to clients' personal and professional lives.
Divorce
Our divorce practice handles complex asset division, child custody, and spousal support matters. We employ collaborative strategies while maintaining trial readiness to protect client interests. The firm's experience includes high-net-worth divorces and cases involving business ownership disputes.
Personal Injury
We represent injury victims in car accident and negligence cases, seeking compensation for medical expenses and lost wages. Our litigation approach combines settlement negotiation skills with courtroom experience to maximize recovery. We handle cases involving insurance disputes and catastrophic injuries.
Business Litigation
The firm resolves business conflicts through litigation and alternative dispute resolution. Practice areas include contract disputes, partnership disagreements, and real estate litigation. We provide strategic counsel to minimize operational disruption while achieving favorable financial outcomes for business clients.
People
John Jay McArthur
Attorney
With 35+ years of experience, John specializes in criminal defense and civil litigation. A University of Georgia Law graduate, he has secured significant verdicts in DUI, drug, and felony cases while maintaining an active role in youth sports coaching.
Sara Miller McArthur
Attorney
Sara focuses on criminal defense and family law, serving as Juvenile Court Judge since 1992. A UNC-Chapel Hill and UGA Law graduate, she has tried hundreds of cases and contributes to community organizations including the Northeast Georgia Food Bank.
Questions
What areas of law does McArthur & McArthur specialize in?
We specialize in criminal defense, DUI cases, divorce/family law, personal injury, business litigation, and estate planning. Our attorneys have particular expertise in defending University of Georgia students facing underage possession charges.
How does the firm's small size benefit clients?
Our smaller size allows flexible billing arrangements, personalized attorney access, and tailored legal strategies. Clients receive direct representation from experienced attorneys rather than junior associates.
What experience do your attorneys have in criminal cases?
Our attorneys have 35+ years of combined experience handling state and federal criminal cases, including drug offenses, white-collar crimes, and serious felonies. We've successfully represented clients facing charges from DUI to capital murder.
Do you offer free consultations?
Yes, we provide free telephone consultations for all practice areas. This allows prospective clients to discuss their case details and receive initial legal guidance without financial commitment.
How do you handle college student legal issues?
We specialize in defending UGA students for underage possession of alcohol and related charges. Our approach focuses on minimizing academic and future career consequences while providing aggressive legal representation.