Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Elmira & Corning, NY
Stewart Agency offers tailored insurance solutions designed to meet the unique needs of individuals and businesses in Elmira and Corning, NY. As a trusted independent insurance agency, we prioritize personalized service, working with multiple top-rated insurance companies to custom-build policies that align with our clients' specific requirements. Our experienced team of licensed advisors brings decades of combined expertise in home, auto, life, commercial, and specialty insurance, ensuring comprehensive coverage at competitive rates. We are committed to building long-lasting relationships through open communication, ethical practices, and a deep understanding of the risks our clients face.

From initial consultation to claims support, we guide clients through every step of the insurance process, providing peace of mind and protection for what matters most. Our community-focused approach extends beyond insurance, with team members actively engaged in local activities and dedicated to serving neighbors with integrity. With offices in Elmira and Corning, NY, we combine local knowledge with industry expertise to deliver solutions that safeguard families, assets, and businesses against unforeseen events.
Services
Auto Insurance Home Insurance Commercial Insurance Life Insurance Flood Insurance Motorcycle Insurance Pet Insurance Umbrella Insurance RV Insurance Renters Insurance
Highlights and features
  • We offer personalized insurance solutions tailored to individual and business needs
  • Our team includes licensed advisors with decades of combined industry experience
  • We work with multiple top-rated insurance carriers to ensure competitive rates
  • We provide comprehensive coverage options for homes, vehicles, businesses, and life
  • We prioritize ethical practices and long-term client relationships over sales pressure
Services
Auto Insurance
Auto insurance protects drivers against financial loss from accidents, theft, or vehicle damage. We offer customizable policies including collision, comprehensive, liability, and uninsured motorist coverage. Our agents help New York drivers meet state requirements while ensuring adequate protection for personal and commercial vehicles.
Home Insurance
Home insurance safeguards property owners against damage from storms, theft, and other covered perils. Our policies include dwelling coverage, personal property protection, liability insurance, and additional living expenses. We help Elmira and Corning residents secure comprehensive protection for primary homes and investment properties.
Commercial Insurance
Commercial insurance protects businesses from operational risks including property damage, liability claims, and workers' compensation requirements. We provide tailored solutions for New York companies, addressing industry-specific risks and compliance needs while offering risk management guidance to minimize potential losses.
Life Insurance
Life insurance ensures financial protection for loved ones through tax-free death benefits. We offer term and permanent policies to cover funeral costs, debts, and ongoing living expenses. Our agents help New York clients select appropriate coverage amounts and structures to meet family needs and retirement goals.
Flood Insurance
Flood insurance covers property damage from flooding events not included in standard home policies. We provide specialized coverage for homes and businesses in high-risk areas. Our agents help clients understand flood zone requirements and secure protection against water-related losses.
People
Gregory Stewart
President
With over 35 years in insurance, Gregory holds advanced designations including CFP, ChFC, and CLU. He specializes in comprehensive insurance solutions while maintaining a strong focus on family values and community involvement through local activities and lakefront recreation.
Michelle Ballings
Client Advisor
A licensed advisor with 20+ years of experience, Michelle specializes in home, auto, and commercial insurance. She balances professional expertise with personal interests in gardening, cooking, and animal care while delivering tailored coverage solutions to local clients.
Erin Burgess
Client Advisor
With nine years of experience, Erin provides personalized service backed by extensive insurance knowledge. She focuses on detailed account management while enjoying family time and outdoor activities in New York State parks, bringing a welcoming approach to client relationships.
Bryan Stewart
Client Advisor/Operations Manager
Bryan combines insurance expertise with banking experience to deliver personalized solutions. He assists clients with coverage for major life milestones while maintaining active lifestyle interests including fitness training and exploring local restaurants and destinations.
Krista Snyder
Client Advisor
Krista brings a purpose-driven approach to insurance after transitioning from customer service roles. A mother of twins, she emphasizes family security while applying personal health and wellness achievements to help clients achieve financial protection and community-focused insurance solutions.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide auto, home, life, commercial, flood, motorcycle, pet, umbrella, RV, and renters insurance for individuals and businesses in New York and surrounding states.
Do New York residents need auto insurance?
Yes, New York law requires minimum coverage including $25,000/$50,000 bodily injury and $10,000 property damage. We help drivers meet these requirements with customized policies.
How can I get a home insurance quote?
Contact our Elmira or Corning offices by phone or email to discuss your property details and receive a personalized home insurance quote tailored to your specific needs.
What commercial insurance do businesses need?
New York businesses typically require workers' compensation, general liability, and property insurance. We assess your industry risks to create comprehensive coverage packages that meet regulatory requirements.
Can I purchase life insurance without a medical exam?
Yes, we offer no-exam life insurance options through our Quote & Apply tool, though coverage amounts and rates may vary compared to policies requiring medical underwriting.
How do I file an insurance claim?
Contact our office directly or use your carrier's online portal to initiate a claim. Our team guides you through the process for auto, home, or business insurance claims.