Business Details
36 Years
experience
Welcome to Lake Ontario Motel
Lake Ontario Motel has been a trusted hospitality provider in Niagara County for over 30 years. Our family-owned establishment combines historical charm with modern comforts, offering guests a unique blend of cozy accommodations and strategic proximity to Western New York's premier attractions. We specialize in serving diverse clientele including vacationers, business travelers, and fishing enthusiasts through personalized service and thoughtfully maintained facilities. Our property's transformation from a 1910 barn to contemporary lodging reflects our commitment to preserving local heritage while meeting modern guest expectations.With direct access to Lake Ontario's renowned fishing grounds and convenient proximity to Niagara Falls, we provide exceptional value through affordable rates and specialized amenities like boat parking and fish storage facilities. Our team's deep community roots and extensive hospitality experience ensure every guest receives attentive care and insider knowledge of the region's best attractions.
Services
Accommodations
Fishing Packages
Event Hosting
Boat Storage
Pet-Friendly Stays
Details
- Year established: 1990
Highlights and features
- We offer over 30 years of hospitality experience in Niagara County
- Our property provides direct access to Lake Ontario's premier fishing grounds
- We maintain pet-friendly accommodations with specialized outdoor amenities
- Our family-owned operation ensures personalized guest service
- We provide affordable rates with seasonal complimentary breakfast options
What people say
Quaint but nice
Great, clean place
Very friendly people
Cozy lodging
Repeat guests
Services
Accommodations
Our motel offers comfortable rooms with modern amenities in a historic setting. Guests enjoy easy access to Lake Ontario's fishing spots and Niagara Falls attractions. Rooms include complimentary breakfast options during peak seasons and specialized features like boat parking for outdoor enthusiasts.
Fishing Packages
We provide tailored lodging solutions for fishing enthusiasts with proximity to Lake Ontario's shore, Eighteen Mile Creek, and local charter services. Amenities include fish storage freezers, tournament registration assistance, and strategic location between major fishing destinations.
Pet-Friendly Stays
Our property welcomes pets with designated accommodations that maintain comfort for both animals and owners. This service reflects our commitment to accommodating diverse guest needs while maintaining cleanliness standards.
Event Hosting
We specialize in hosting guests during major fishing events like the LOC Derby. Our location near competition sites and storage facilities for catches makes us ideal for tournament participants seeking convenient accommodations.
Boat Storage
Our property offers secure parking for boats and trailers, providing added convenience for guests arriving with watercraft. This service supports our focus on serving fishing enthusiasts and outdoor adventurers.
People
Brad May
Co-Owner
Co-owner with extensive local business experience. Former sales manager for precision manufacturing, bringing operational expertise to hospitality management.
Paige May
Co-Owner
Co-owner and licensed dental hygienist. Third-generation operator of the family motel business, maintaining continuity since 2018 acquisition from her parents.
Phil Toenniessen
Previous Owner
Retired Great Lakes Coast Guard Captain and charter fishing pioneer. Founding figure in Niagara County's fishing tourism industry with 17 years of charter operation experience.
Jan Toenniessen
Previous Owner
Community leader in local tourism development. Former Niagara County Tourism Board member and publisher of regional fishing organization newsletters.
Questions
What makes your motel ideal for fishing trips?
We're 10 minutes from Lake Ontario's shore with boat parking, fish storage, and proximity to charter services and fishing tournaments.
Do you offer special rates for extended stays?
Our Four-Single Bedrooms accommodate groups at $112/night, with single rooms from $72-$81 depending on season.
Are pets allowed on the property?
Yes, we're pet-friendly with designated accommodations that maintain comfort for both animals and owners.
How close are you to Niagara Falls?
We're 30 minutes from both American and Canadian Niagara Falls attractions with convenient highway access.
Do you provide breakfast options?
Complimentary breakfast is available seasonally, with contactless check-in options during winter months.
