Business Details
27 Years
experience
Authentic Italian Cuisine & Catering in Mastic, NY
Mama Lisa Restaurant was established in 1999 by Gaetano and Mose Costigliola, building on their father Carlo Costigliola's legacy as owner of Umbertos, a successful Italian restaurant in Patchogue for over fifteen years. Our family-style recipes originate from Italy and have been passed down through generations, forming the foundation of our culinary identity. We prioritize selection, offering a wide array of Italian dishes crafted with fresh, locally sourced ingredients from Mastic businesses. Accessibility remains central to our approach, with minimal wait times and flexible dining options including in-house service, takeout, and local delivery. Our commitment to exceptional customer service ensures attentive care and a welcoming atmosphere for every guest.Competitive pricing guarantees value without compromising quality, while our community focus drives partnerships with local merchants and sponsorship of schools, sports teams, and charitable events. The restaurant's evolution from a small establishment to a larger venue further up the road reflects our dedication to maintaining authentic homemade dishes and house wines that pair perfectly with every meal. Our loyal customer base, some of whom have supported us for over 22 years, attests to the consistency of our quality and service. Whether dining in or ordering takeout, we remain committed to delivering the same exceptional experience that has defined Mama Lisa Restaurant for decades.
Services
Italian Restaurant
Catering Services
Online Ordering
Reservations
Takeout/Delivery
Details
- Year established: 1999
Highlights and features
- We offer family recipes passed down through generations for authentic Italian flavors
- Our ingredients are sourced fresh daily from local Mastic businesses
- We provide customized catering services for events of all sizes
- Competitive pricing maintains quality without compromising value
- 22-year legacy of loyal customers attests to our consistent excellence
What people say
Delicious & fresh
Amazing service
Best Italian food
Warm & welcoming
Fresh hot calamari
Services
Italian Restaurant
Our full-service restaurant serves traditional Italian dishes made from family recipes passed down through generations. Each meal features house-made pasta, fresh seafood, and locally sourced vegetables prepared daily. The warm, inviting atmosphere accommodates both casual diners and special celebrations with attentive service.
Catering Services
Customized catering solutions for weddings, corporate events, and private parties feature our signature Italian cuisine. We provide complete service from menu design to table settings, using the same quality ingredients as our restaurant. Our team handles all details to ensure memorable events with exceptional food and presentation.
Online Ordering
Convenient online system allows customers to customize and track orders from our full menu. Freshly prepared meals maintain quality during pickup with minimal wait times. User-friendly interface supports special requests while maintaining the same authentic flavors that made us a local favorite for over two decades.
Reservations
Table reservation system ensures availability for lunch and dinner service. Recommended for weekends and special occasions, our reservation process accommodates parties of all sizes. Advance booking guarantees seating in our main dining area with comfortable table arrangements.
Takeout/Delivery
Local delivery and takeout options provide restaurant-quality meals at home. Fresh ingredients maintain integrity during transport with specialized packaging. Same-day service available for lunch and dinner, featuring our complete menu including signature dishes like Penne Alla Vodka and Sicilian pizza.
People
Gaetano Costigliola
Co-Owner
Co-founder with over two decades of experience in Italian hospitality, continuing family culinary traditions from his father Carlo's original restaurant in Patchogue.
Mose Costigliola
Co-Owner
Co-owner maintaining authentic Italian cooking methods passed through generations, ensuring consistent quality in every dish served at the restaurant.
Questions
What makes Mama Lisa Restaurant's Italian food unique?
Our family recipes passed down through generations create authentic flavors. We use fresh local ingredients daily and maintain traditional cooking methods from our original Patchogue restaurant.
Do you offer catering services for special events?
Yes, we provide full-service catering with customized menus and table settings for weddings, corporate events, and private parties of all sizes.
Can I order food online for pickup or delivery?
Yes, our user-friendly online system allows ordering any menu item for pickup or local delivery with real-time tracking from preparation to completion.
Are reservations recommended for weekend dining?
Yes, we recommend reservations for weekends and special occasions to guarantee seating, though walk-ins are always welcome when space permits.
What areas do you deliver to from your restaurant?
We provide local delivery to Mastic and surrounding areas with the same quality and freshness as our dine-in and takeout options.
