Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Artisan Baked Goods & Pastries in Nantucket
Wicked Island Bakery was founded by Ben and Heather Woodbury, a husband-and-wife team combining over 35 years of culinary and hospitality expertise. Ben, a graduate of the French Culinary Institute with two decades of experience working alongside renowned chefs, specializes in rustic European breads and baked goods crafted from scratch using time-honored techniques. Heather contributes 15 years of restaurant management experience, infusing our operations with Southern hospitality and a commitment to exceptional customer service. Our mission centers on returning wholesome, natural food to the table by sourcing ingredients locally from trusted merchants, ensuring every product contains pronounceable components and no artificial additives. We prioritize small-batch production using personal recipes developed by our chefs, emphasizing seasonal ingredients from Nantucket, Cape Cod, and New England. Our dedication to quality is evident in our use of premium materials: 83% European-style butter, King Arthur Flour, Belgian chocolate, fresh vanilla beans, and uncured nitrate-free meats.

This philosophy extends to our daily menu featuring artisan breads like Struan with 21 grains and seeds, signature pastries including the iconic Nantucket Morning Bun made with Vermont butter and Tahitian vanilla, and decadent cakes such as the flourless Blackhearts Truffle Chocolate Cake. Every item reflects our belief that exceptional ingredients and traditional methods create unparalleled flavor experiences. We maintain rigorous standards across all offerings, from savory options like house-made sausage in our Toad in the Hole to complex spice blends in our cinnamon rolls. Our team's extensive industry experience and passion for baking excellence position us as a trusted provider of artisanal baked goods in the region.
Services
Morning Buns Signature Cakes Artisan Breads Breakfast Pastries Custom Cakes House-Made Croissants Belgian Chocolate Treats Savory Sandwiches Seasonal Baked Goods Gift Cards
Highlights and features
  • We use only premium ingredients like 83% European-style butter and King Arthur Flour
  • Our recipes combine traditional techniques with local seasonal ingredients
  • Ben Woodbury brings 20 years of experience working with world-class chefs
  • We prioritize small-batch production for consistent quality
  • Our menu features both classic and innovative baked goods daily
What people say
Perfect caramelization Exceptional quality Skilled execution Fresh ingredients Consistent favorites
Services
Morning Buns
Our signature Nantucket Morning Buns feature layers of flaky dough made with pure Vermont butter, Tahitian vanilla beans, and proprietary spice blends. Each bun undergoes a 48-hour preparation process to develop complex flavors and achieve perfect caramelization. Customers consistently return for this scratch-made treat that combines European baking traditions with local ingredients.
Signature Cakes
We create specialty cakes like the flourless Blackhearts Truffle Chocolate Cake with dark chocolate marquise and bittersweet ganache. Our cheesecakes use gingersnap crusts and caramelized tops, while carrot cakes feature dense spice blends and creamy frosting. All cakes use premium Belgian chocolate and fresh ingredients without artificial additives.
Artisan Breads
Our Struan bread combines 21 grains and seeds in a single loaf using traditional fermentation methods. Daily offerings include sourdoughs, baguettes, and specialty breads made with King Arthur Flour and natural starters. Each loaf follows time-tested techniques to develop optimal texture and flavor complexity.
Breakfast Pastries
House-made croissants come in classic butter, ham and Swiss, almond marzipan, or Belgian chocolate varieties. Our cinnamon rolls use Saigon cinnamon and house-made fillings, while quick breads feature seasonal ingredients like Maine blueberries and Nantucket cranberries in rotating daily selections.
Savory Sandwiches
Breakfast sandwiches like The Islander combine local farm eggs, house-cured bacon, and Vermont cheddar on freshly baked bread. The Hangover special features double bacon, double cheese, and house-made sausage. All components are prepared in-house daily using premium ingredients.
People
Ben Woodbury
Executive Chef
Graduate of the French Culinary Institute with 20 years of experience working alongside world-renowned chefs. Specializes in rustic European breads and baked goods using traditional techniques.
Heather Woodbury
General Manager
Brings 15 years of restaurant management experience and Southern hospitality to our operations. Oversees daily operations and customer service with a focus on community connections.
Questions
What makes your Morning Buns special?
Our Nantucket Morning Buns use a 48-hour preparation process with Vermont butter and Tahitian vanilla beans for complex flavor development.
Do you offer custom cake orders?
Yes, we create custom cakes like our flourless Blackhearts Truffle Chocolate Cake using premium Belgian chocolate and fresh ingredients.
Are your products made in-house?
All items are made from scratch in our bakery using house recipes and traditional techniques without pre-made components.
What bread varieties do you offer?
We feature Struan with 21 grains, sourdoughs, baguettes, and specialty breads using King Arthur Flour and natural starters.
Do you use local ingredients?
We prioritize local sourcing from Nantucket and Cape Cod merchants for seasonal ingredients in our daily offerings.
What breakfast options are available?
Our breakfast menu includes house-made croissants, cinnamon rolls, quick breads, and sandwiches like The Islander with house-cured bacon.