Business Details
20 Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Venice, FL
Shaefer Insurance Agency has been serving South Florida since 2006, providing tailored insurance solutions to meet diverse client needs. As a family-owned and operated independent agency, we prioritize understanding each client's unique circumstances to recommend policies that balance affordability and comprehensive coverage. Our commitment to transparency ensures clients receive unbiased advice, with access to competitive rates across home, auto, life, and flood insurance.We pride ourselves on building lasting relationships through personalized service, prompt communication, and a focus on educating clients about their options. With decades of combined experience in the insurance industry, we represent reputable carriers to deliver reliable protection while maintaining a client-first approach that emphasizes trust and accountability.
Services
Home Insurance
Car Insurance
Boat Insurance
Life Insurance
Flood Insurance
Motorcycle Insurance
RV Insurance
Term Life Insurance
Whole Life Insurance
Details
- Year established: 2006
Highlights and features
- We are a family-owned agency with 17+ years of local insurance expertise.
- Our independent status allows unbiased recommendations from top-rated carriers.
- We guarantee competitive pricing on home, auto, and flood insurance policies.
- Our team provides personalized guidance to match policies with client needs.
- We offer free insurance consultations and quote comparisons for all services.
What people say
Easy to work with
Very honest
Awesome communication
Highly recommend
Delight to deal with
Services
Home Insurance
Home insurance protects your property and belongings against damage, theft, or natural disasters. We offer policies tailored to Florida's unique risks, including hurricane-related damage. Our agents help clients select coverage that balances affordability with comprehensive protection for their homes and personal assets.
Car Insurance
Car insurance provides liability and collision coverage for vehicles, meeting Florida's legal requirements while protecting against financial loss. We compare rates from top-rated carriers to find policies that suit driving records, vehicle values, and individual needs. Our team explains coverage options to ensure informed decisions.
Boat Insurance
Boat insurance safeguards watercraft against damage, theft, or liability while on the water. We offer policies with optional benefits like on-water towing and roadside assistance. Our agents help clients understand liability limits and available discounts for multi-policy bundling or safety course completions.
Life Insurance
Life insurance ensures financial stability for beneficiaries through death benefits covering debts, funeral costs, or income replacement. We provide term and permanent policies tailored to family needs, with guidance on coverage amounts and cash-value options. Our approach focuses on long-term planning and affordability.
Flood Insurance
Flood insurance covers property damage from water events not included in standard home policies. We educate clients on risks in low-to-moderate zones and help secure coverage through the National Flood Insurance Program. Our agency explains policy details and assists with claims preparation.
People
Brian Shaefer
Owner
Brian Shaefer founded the agency to provide independent, client-focused insurance solutions. With decades of experience in Florida's evolving insurance market, he leads a team dedicated to matching client needs with reputable carriers. His approach emphasizes transparency, education, and personalized service.
Questions
What types of insurance does Shaefer Insurance Agency offer?
We offer home, car, boat, life, flood, motorcycle, and RV insurance, including term and whole life policies. Our independent status allows us to compare options from multiple carriers.
How can I lower my auto insurance costs?
Maintain a clean driving record, consider higher deductibles, install safety features, or bundle policies. Our agents help identify discounts and tailor coverage to reduce premiums while maintaining protection.
Is flood insurance required in Venice, FL?
Flood insurance is mandatory for properties in high-risk zones with federally backed mortgages. We recommend it for all homeowners, as 25% of claims occur in low-risk areas due to unexpected water damage.
Do you provide free insurance quotes?
Yes, we offer free, no-obligation quotes for all services. Contact us via phone or our website to request personalized comparisons from top-rated carriers.
How does being an independent agency benefit me?
We represent multiple carriers, allowing unbiased recommendations based on your needs rather than a single company's interests. This ensures competitive pricing and tailored coverage options.
