Business Details
Your Historic Stay in Algoma, WI
Hotel Stebbins has been a cornerstone of Algoma, Wisconsin, since 1857, offering a unique blend of historic charm and modern hospitality. As Algoma's only full-service hotel, we pride ourselves on providing personalized experiences through our owner-operated service, recently revitalized accommodations, and commitment to preserving the property's rich legacy. Our 10 distinct rooms and suites, including themed options with full kitchens, cater to diverse guest needs while maintaining the building's original architectural character. The hotel's first-floor amenities feature a classic supper club, game room, and banquet facilities that serve both visitors and the local community. With strategic renovations completed in 2015, we've restored historic elements like 1905 tin ceilings while incorporating contemporary comforts such as free wireless internet and modern room amenities.Our staff treats every guest to a 'respite' experience, combining traditional hospitality with 21st-century convenience. Located just two blocks from Lake Michigan, we offer proximity to cultural attractions like the Ahnapee Trail and von Stiehl Winery. As stewards of this historic property, we maintain its legacy through partnerships with local businesses for event services and catering. Our operational philosophy emphasizes creating lasting memories through personalized service rather than generic hospitality. This approach has made us a trusted destination for both leisure travelers and event planners seeking authentic Wisconsin experiences.
Services
Accommodations
Restaurant & Bar
Banquet Facilities
Event Planning
Amenities Room
Highlights and features
- We offer Algoma's only full-service hotel experience with continuous operation since 1857
- Our 10 uniquely themed rooms combine historic preservation with modern amenities
- Personalized 'Inn' experience through owner-operated service and attention to detail
- Strategic location two blocks from Lake Michigan and near major local attractions
- Comprehensive event services with banquet facilities and partnered local vendors
Services
Accommodations
Our 10 uniquely themed rooms and suites offer historic charm with modern comforts. Each space features distinct decor, private bathrooms, and modern amenities like flat-screen TVs and refrigerators. Guests enjoy curated experiences blending 1857 architectural elements with contemporary conveniences in Algoma's only full-service hotel.
Restaurant & Bar
The historic supper club and bar serve nightly specials including Wisconsin fish fry and steak dinners. Our menu combines traditional Midwestern cuisine with modern presentation in a setting featuring original 1905 architectural details and classic cocktail lounge ambiance.
Banquet Facilities
Our event space accommodates up to 40 guests with customized banquet menus and full-service hosting. The venue features a dedicated pool room, partnered local vendors for floral and bakery services, and historic ambiance suitable for weddings, business meetings, and special celebrations.
Amenities Room
The amenities room provides essential services including coin-operated laundry, ice machine, and snack/soda vending. This 24/7 accessible space supports extended stays with practical conveniences while maintaining the hotel's historic character through preserved architectural elements.
Event Planning
We offer comprehensive event planning with venue selection, customized menus, and partnerships with local businesses. Services include floral arrangements from Steele St. Floral and specialty desserts from Northwater Bakery, creating seamless experiences for weddings and special occasions.
Questions
What historical significance does Hotel Stebbins hold?
Built in 1857 as Algoma's first framed building, it's Wisconsin's oldest continuously operating hotel with original 1905 tin ceilings and historic architectural elements preserved.
What room types are available?
We offer 10 distinct units including kitchen suites with full amenities, standard suites with multiple sleeping arrangements, and uniquely themed standard rooms.
Are event hosting services available?
Yes, our banquet facilities accommodate up to 40 guests with customized menus, pool room entertainment, and partnerships with local florists and bakeries for complete event services.
What nearby attractions are accessible?
Located two blocks from Lake Michigan, we're near von Stiehl Winery, Ahnapee Trail, marina, boardwalk, art studios, and downtown shopping within Algoma's historic district.
What modern amenities are provided?
Rooms feature flat-screen TVs, refrigerators, coffee makers, A/C, and free wireless internet in public areas, plus amenities room with laundry and vending services.
