Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Seville, OH
Established in Seville, Ohio in 1972, Plumer Insurance, Inc. has dedicated over five decades to serving individuals, families, and businesses across northern Ohio. With a team boasting more than 75 combined years of experience, we leverage advanced technology for instant insurance comparisons and personalized service. Our commitment to reducing client costs and closing coverage gaps ensures tailored protection programs that align with your unique needs. We prioritize prompt claims settlements, regular policy reviews, and budget-friendly payment plans to deliver reliable, cost-effective solutions.

Backed by partnerships with leading insurers like Erie Insurance Group and Progressive, we offer comprehensive coverage options for auto, home, life, health, and commercial insurance. Our local expertise and dedication to community service, including volunteer work with Westfield Fire & Rescue and Cloverleaf Local Schools Board of Education, underscore our trusted reputation. Whether you seek classic motorcycle insurance or commercial property coverage, our team provides expert guidance to secure your financial future.
Services
Auto Insurance Home Insurance Life Insurance Health Insurance Commercial Insurance
Details
  • Year established: 1972
Highlights and features
  • We offer over 50 years of local insurance expertise.
  • Our team provides personalized coverage comparisons using advanced technology.
  • We partner with top-rated insurers like Erie and Progressive.
  • We prioritize cost-saving strategies and budget payment plans.
  • Our claims process emphasizes prompt, fair settlements.
Services
Auto Insurance
Plumer Insurance offers comprehensive auto insurance tailored to protect drivers and vehicles. We provide liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage options, ensuring compliance with legal requirements while safeguarding against financial loss from accidents or damage. Our partnerships with top insurers like Erie Insurance Group and Progressive enable competitive pricing and specialized policies for classic cars, motorcycles, and high-performance vehicles.
Home Insurance
Our homeowners insurance programs cover one- or two-family homes, modular, condominiums, and mobile homes. Policies are customized based on property age, construction, and features to address risks like fire, theft, and natural disasters. We collaborate with providers such as National General Insurance and Ohio Fair Plan to deliver affordable, reliable coverage that protects your most valuable asset.
Life Insurance
Plumer Insurance offers term life and universal life insurance policies to secure your family's financial future. These plans provide death benefits to cover debts, funeral costs, or income replacement. We work with insurers like Mass Mutual and Genworth to design policies that align with your long-term goals, including annuities and pension plans for retirement security.
Health Insurance
We provide group and individual health insurance solutions to meet diverse medical needs. Our offerings include plans with flexible deductibles, prescription coverage, and access to extensive provider networks. Partnering with AFLAC and Central Reserve Life, we help clients navigate options for comprehensive care, disability insurance, and supplemental policies to reduce out-of-pocket expenses.
Commercial Insurance
Our commercial insurance packages safeguard businesses against property damage, liability claims, and operational disruptions. Coverage includes commercial property, general liability, auto fleet policies, and excess liability protection. We specialize in tailored solutions for contractors, manufacturers, and service providers, leveraging insurers like Western Reserve Group to ensure comprehensive risk management for northern Ohio enterprises.
People
James Harris
Owner
James Harris, owner of Plumer Insurance, holds a Bachelor of Science from Kent State University and over 25 years of insurance experience. He specializes in property, casualty, and life insurance, combining local expertise with a commitment to community service through volunteer firefighting and coaching.
Emma Bair
Insurance Agent
Emma Bair brings management and insurance experience from the vendor side to Plumer Insurance. A Chippewa High School graduate, she focuses on personalized client service and enjoys outdoor activities like hiking and kayaking while contributing to the agency's growth.
Jane Rych
Licensed Agent
Jane Rych, with 37 years in insurance, holds certifications including FLMI and CISR. She specializes in personal lines coverage and serves on the Cloverleaf Local Schools Board of Education, blending industry expertise with community involvement through volunteer emergency services.
Darla Gordon Payn
Clerical Staff
Darla Gordon Payn supports Plumer Insurance with clerical work, drawing on 17 years of retail experience and 35 years in trucking. She contributes organizational skills and local knowledge while enjoying gardening and family time in Seville.
Tyler Harris
Intern
Tyler Harris, a Kent State University business student, assists with administrative tasks at Plumer Insurance. An active athlete and outdoor enthusiast, he gains hands-on experience in insurance operations while pursuing his degree.
Questions
What types of insurance does Plumer Insurance Agency offer?
We provide auto, home, life, health, and commercial insurance, including specialized coverage for motorcycles, classic cars, and business properties.
How can Plumer Insurance help me save money?
We analyze your needs, compare rates from top insurers, and identify discounts to create cost-effective policies tailored to your situation.
Do you offer coverage for unique vehicles like motorcycles?
Yes, we partner with Progressive to insure 99% of motorcycles, including cruisers, dirt bikes, and vintage models.
What areas do you serve?
We primarily serve northern Ohio, providing personalized insurance solutions for individuals and businesses in the region.
Can I get a no-obligation insurance review?
Yes, we offer free, no-obligation policy reviews to ensure your coverage meets current needs and budget.
How do you handle insurance claims?
We prioritize prompt, fair claims settlements and guide you through the process to ensure timely resolution and support.