Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
7 Years
experience
Your Trusted Bakery & Cafe in Port St. Joe, FL
Founded in 2019, Bayside Bakery began as a home-based operation in St. Joe Beach, FL, with a mission to deliver scratch-made baked goods of exceptional quality to the Forgotten Coast community. Recognizing rapid growth and demand, the business expanded into a full-service bakery, cafe, and coffee house located at 108 1st St in downtown Port St. Joe. Our commitment to excellence extends beyond products to fostering safe, fulfilling jobs for employees and active community engagement. We specialize in custom cakes for celebrations, seasonal specialties like pumpkin breads and spiced muffins, and light cafe lunches paired with locally roasted coffee.

Our core values emphasize efficiency, respect, and innovation, ensuring every customer interaction reflects our dedication to quality and service. With preordering options and a focus on convenience, we aim to simplify your holiday and event planning while maintaining the authenticity of homemade baking. Our team takes pride in crafting desserts that elevate gatherings, from intimate family meals to large-scale weddings, all while maintaining the highest standards of freshness and flavor.
Services
Custom Cakes Bakery Items Cafe Services Wedding Cakes Seasonal Specials
Details
  • Year established: 2019
Highlights and features
  • We offer 6+ years of experience in artisanal baking and custom cake design.
  • Our scratch-made recipes use locally sourced ingredients for superior flavor.
  • We provide personalized wedding cake consultations and tiered serving options.
  • Our team prioritizes community involvement and sustainable business practices.
  • We guarantee fresh daily baking and convenient preordering for holiday seasons.
Services
Custom Cakes
We create bespoke cakes for weddings, holidays, and special events using scratch-made recipes and premium ingredients. Our options include tiered designs, seasonal flavors, and dietary accommodations. Each cake features customizable decorations and serving sizes to match client visions.
Bakery Items
Our daily bakery menu features artisanal breads, pastries, and desserts made from scratch in-house. Seasonal specialties like pumpkin breads and spiced muffins complement year-round favorites including quiches, cookies, and espresso drinks.
Cafe Services
The cafe offers light lunch options, locally roasted coffee, and espresso drinks in a welcoming downtown Port St. Joe location. Guests can dine in, take meals to-go, or order catering for boat outings and social gatherings.
Wedding Cakes
We specialize in wedding cakes with tiered serving options, custom flavor combinations, and decorative elements. Services include consultations, flavor testing, and serving guides to ensure perfect portions for reception sizes.
Seasonal Specials
Our seasonal menu features limited-time items like Thanksgiving pies, Christmas cupcakes, and specialty breads. Preordering guarantees availability during peak holiday periods with cutoff dates clearly communicated to customers.
People
Mikayla McKee
Owner
Mikayla founded Bayside Bakery in 2019 after identifying a need for quality scratch-made baked goods on Florida's Forgotten Coast. She oversees all operations while maintaining hands-on involvement in recipe development and customer service.
Questions
How do I preorder seasonal baked goods?
Place orders through our website before the specified cutoff date. Payment is required at checkout to guarantee availability during busy holiday periods.
What cake flavors do you offer for weddings?
We provide vanilla, chocolate, marble, carrot, red velvet, almond, lemon, funfetti, and gluten-free options with various icings and fillings.
Do you cater to dietary restrictions?
We offer gluten-free and vegan options for select items. Please discuss specific dietary needs with our staff when placing orders.
What areas do you serve?
We primarily serve Port St. Joe and the surrounding Forgotten Coast region, with delivery options available for large orders.
Can I customize my cupcake flavors?
Yes! Choose from basic, premium, or specialty flavors including salted caramel, chocolate ganache, and cookies & cream for custom cupcake orders.