Website Call now
Website
Call

At Mayfly Market & Deli, we're more than just a neighborhood market - we're your neighbor. We're committed to providing Pittsburgh's North Side with delicious fare and friendly service. Our mission is to bring delicious, healthy foods and convenience to our community, stocking only fresh, quality foods and sundries. From fruits and vegetables to meat, cheese, and bread, we've got a little something for everyone.

Our Story

Mayfly Market & Deli is proudly located on Arch Street in Pittsburgh, PA, and we're proud to be a part of this vibrant community. We're a locally owned market, dedicated to supporting our neighbors and providing the best possible products and services. Our team is passionate about food, community, and customer service, and we strive to make every interaction with Mayfly a positive one.

Our Services

We offer a wide range of services and products, including:

  • Produce: Fresh, high-quality fruits and vegetables, sourced locally whenever possible.
  • Deli: Made-to-order sandwiches, salads, and spreads, all made in-house with love and care.
  • Staples: All the basics, from milk and eggs to canned and dry goods, and household items.
  • Baked Goods: Delicious cookies and confections, baked fresh daily.
  • Coffee: Featuring coffee from our North Side neighbors, Commonplace and La Prima.
  • Fresh Bread: Fresh breads from Pittsburgh's Mediterra Bakehouse and Pane e Pronto.
  • Sorbet: Seasonal, handcrafted sorbets from Gilligan's Sorbet.
  • Floral: Beautiful flower arrangements and houseplants from our friends at Root Seller.

We're also happy to offer catering services for events, and our team is always happy to help with any special requests or orders.

Our Commitment

At Mayfly Market & Deli, we're committed to providing the best possible products and services to our community. We believe in supporting local businesses and farmers, and we're dedicated to reducing our environmental impact. We're proud to be a part of Pittsburgh's North Side, and we look forward to serving you!

Reviews
Positive: The reviews are overwhelmingly positive, praising the store's atmosphere, food, and products.
Negative: The negative review criticizes the store's refusal to accommodate customizations on deli items, making it difficult for customers with allergies or dietary restrictions to enjoy the store's food.

Lifestyle and Atmosphere

The reviews reveal a strong sense of community and warm atmosphere at Mayfly's Market. Many customers praise the store's beautiful old building, the art and flowers, and the friendly staff. The store's location in the Northside neighborhood is also a major selling point, with several reviewers mentioning its proximity to other local attractions.

Food and Products

The market's food and products are a major focus of the reviews. Customers rave about the sandwiches, salads, and baked goods, with several reviewers specifically mentioning the delicious seasonal offerings. Many reviewers also praise the store's selection of local and artisanal products, including fresh produce, meats, and cheeses.

Values and Convenience

Mayfly's Market is praised for its emphasis on local and sustainable products, as well as its convenient online inventory spreadsheet. Several reviewers also mention the store's willingness to accommodate special requests and dietary needs.

One Negative Review

However, one reviewer expresses deep disappointment with the store's switch to non-customizable deli items. The reviewer feels that this change makes it difficult for customers with allergies or dietary restrictions to enjoy the store's food.

Review Mayfly Market & Deli

Be the first to review Mayfly Market & Deli.

Write a Review