Business Details
7 Years
experience
Your Local Phoenix Pizza Shop Serving NY Style Thin Crust Pizza
My Slice Of The Pie Pizzeria Arcadia is a family-owned and operated business that has been serving Phoenix, Arizona since 2019. We specialize in authentic New York-style thin crust pizza, uniquely fused with Mexican and Southwestern flavors through ingredients like al pastor, roasted corn, and fire-roasted jalapeos. Our commitment to quality is evident in our daily preparation of fresh dough, use of premium cheeses like mozzarella and cotija, and slow-baking in a stone oven to achieve perfect texture.With six years of experience perfecting our sourdough crust for Arizona's climate, we've earned recognition as the highest-rated pizza shop in the Arcadia area. Our menu extends beyond pizza to include house-made pastas, fresh salads, and catering services for events of all sizes, maintaining the same dedication to quality that earned us Yelp's 2023 Best Pizza Shop in Arizona award.
Services
NY Style Thin Crust Pizza
Catering Services
Pizza Delivery
Takeout Orders
Dine In Experience
Al Pastor Pizza
House-Made Pastas
Fresh Salads
Event Catering
Stone Oven Pizza
Details
- Year established: 2019
Highlights and features
- We offer six years of expertise perfecting NY-style pizza crust for Arizona's climate
- Our stone oven pizzas use premium cheeses like mozzarella and cotija daily
- We provide catering services for events from small offices to weddings
- Our menu features house-made pastas and fresh salads alongside signature pizzas
- We deliver beyond our 3-mile radius to serve the entire Phoenix metro area
What people say
Best pizza in Phoenix
Fresh ingredients daily
Prompt delivery service
Exceptional El Pastor pizza
Perfect stone oven crust
Services
NY Style Thin Crust Pizza
Our signature NY-style thin crust pizza uses a perfected sourdough recipe tailored for Arizona's climate. Slow-baked in a stone oven for optimal texture, each pie features premium cheeses like mozzarella and cotija. Toppings range from traditional pepperoni to Southwestern-inspired combinations with al pastor and fire-roasted jalapeos.
Catering Services
We cater events from small office meetings to large weddings with our NY-style pizzas and house-made accompaniments. Menu options include 18-inch specialty pizzas, party-sized salads like The Casa and Antipasto, and pasta dishes such as our spicy marinara spaghetti. Delivery available throughout Phoenix metro area for events beyond our regular radius.
Pizza Delivery
Enjoy our fresh, stone-oven pizzas delivered directly to your Phoenix location. While our standard delivery radius is 3 miles, we extend service to offices, schools, and large groups throughout the metro area. Orders can be placed online or by phone for prompt delivery of our signature Southwest-fusion and traditional NY-style pizzas.
House-Made Pastas
Our menu features house-made pastas complementing our pizza offerings. Choose from spicy marinara spaghetti with optional meatballs, classic lasagna with Schreiners sausage and cheeses, or our kids' spaghetti with NY pizza sauce. All pasta dishes use fresh ingredients prepared daily in our kitchen.
Fresh Salads
We offer three signature salads made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. The Casa features a lettuce blend with tomato and cucumber, while the Antipasto includes salami and roasted artichoke. Our Lil Caesar provides traditional romaine with croutons and shaved parmesan, all made to order using daily-prepared components.
Questions
What makes your pizza different from other Phoenix pizzerias?
Our NY-style thin crust pizza uses a sourdough recipe perfected for Arizona's climate, slow-baked in stone ovens. We uniquely blend traditional NY flavors with Southwest ingredients like al pastor and fire-roasted jalapeños.
Do you offer catering services for large events?
Yes, we cater events from small office meetings to weddings with our NY-style pizzas, house-made pastas, and fresh salads. We deliver throughout Phoenix metro area for large groups beyond our regular 3-mile radius.
What are your most popular menu items?
Our El Pastor pizza with grilled pineapple and our traditional pepperoni are top sellers. We also serve house-made pastas, fresh salads like The Casa, and our Lil Caesar with shaved parmesan.
Can I order online for delivery or pickup?
Yes, our website allows online ordering for delivery, takeout, or dine-in. You can also call us directly at 602-956-2098 to place your order.
What are your current pizza deals?
We offer a 14" 1-topping pizza with 10 wings for $24.99 and an 18" 1-topping pizza with 20 wings for $37.99. These specials are available from 5PM until closing.
