Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Fresh Baked Goods & Pastries Since 1920
Since 1920, New System Bakery has been dedicated to crafting high-quality baked goods with a commitment to tradition and customer satisfaction. Our team begins each day at 2:30 AM, preparing fresh dough and hand-making a wide variety of donuts, including our signature Bismarks, glazed twists, and cream cheese croissants. We pride ourselves on using time-honored recipes to create daily batches of cookies, pastries, and seasonal specialties like our Iced Butter Cookies, available year-round due to popular demand. Our menu features over a dozen cookie varieties, fresh muffins, fudge brownies, and decadent Whoopee pies, all made with premium ingredients.

We specialize in custom birthday cakes with simple, elegant decorations, offering multiple flavors and sizes to suit any celebration. Our dedication to quality extends to daily fruit pies, tarts, and our original 1920 recipe brownies, ensuring every customer experiences the same excellence that has defined us for over a century. Located in Chillicothe, Ohio, we serve both walk-in customers and special orders, combining local tradition with nationwide recognition for our baked goods.
Services
Donuts Cookies Birthday Cakes Pastries Brownies
Details
  • Year established: 1920
Highlights and features
  • We offer daily fresh-baked goods made from time-honored recipes since 1920
  • Our signature Bismarks and seasonal specialties are available year-round
  • We provide over a dozen cookie varieties and custom birthday cake options
  • Our team maintains century-old baking traditions with modern quality standards
  • We serve both walk-in customers and special orders with personalized service
Services
Donuts
Our handcrafted donuts feature classic varieties like Bismarks, glazed twists, and cream cheese croissants. Made fresh daily using traditional methods since 1920, these treats combine perfect texture with rich flavors. Available in multiple styles, our donuts remain a customer favorite for breakfast or anytime indulgence.
Cookies
We offer over a dozen cookie varieties including butterscotch, chocolate chip, and our signature Iced Butter Cookies. Seasonal specialties now available year-round feature buttercream icing and decorative elements. All cookies are made daily using time-tested recipes that ensure consistent quality and taste.
Birthday Cakes
Custom birthday cakes come in multiple sizes and flavors like vanilla, chocolate, and carrot. Decorated with traditional white icing, our simple yet elegant designs include personalized writing and decorative borders. Available by special order with advance notice.
Pastries
Daily pastries include fresh muffins, fudge brownies, and Whoopee pies with homemade chocolate cake filling. Our fruit pies and tarts feature seasonal flavors like cherry, blueberry, and coconut cream. All pastries use premium ingredients for authentic taste and quality.
Brownies
Our original 1920 recipe brownies feature rich chocolate fudge frosting and a dense, moist texture. Made in small batches daily, these decadent treats maintain the same quality standards that have defined our bakery for over a century.
Questions
What are your most popular items?
Our best-selling products include Bismarks, Iced Butter Cookies, and custom birthday cakes. We also specialize in seasonal specialties and daily fresh pastries.
Do you offer custom cake designs?
Yes, we create custom birthday cakes with simple decorations including white icing, writing, roses, and borders. Sizes range from 6-inch to full sheet cakes.
Are your products made fresh daily?
We prepare all baked goods fresh daily starting at 2:30 AM, including donuts, cookies, pastries, and our original 1920 recipe brownies.
What cookie varieties do you offer?
We make butterscotch, chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, white chocolate macadamia nut, and seasonal varieties like our Iced Butter Cookies year-round.
Can I order special items in advance?
Yes, we accept special orders for fruit pies, tarts, and custom cakes. Please call ahead to discuss your specific requirements and availability.