Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
15 Years
experience
Custom Gourmet Desserts in Columbus, Ohio
Established in 2011 as a home bakery and expanded to a commercial storefront in 2019, Fate Cakes is a woman-owned business dedicated to crafting gourmet desserts with artistic precision. Our owner, Marie Johns, combines a background in art with a passion for baking to create custom cupcakes, cakes, cookies, and specialty desserts for weddings, birthdays, graduations, and corporate events. All products are handmade daily in-house using high-quality ingredients, with a focus on personalized service and budget-friendly options.

We offer local delivery in Columbus, Ohio, and surrounding areas, including Westerville and Central Ohio, with same-day and next-day options available through DoorDash. Our commitment to excellence is reflected in our attention to detail, from intricate fondant designs to themed 3D cakes, ensuring every order meets the unique needs of our clients while maintaining the highest standards of quality and freshness.
Services
Custom Cakes Cupcakes Cookies Wedding Cakes Birthday Cakes Delivery Services Cake Tasting Boxes Graduation Cakes Themed Cakes Catering Services
Details
  • Year established: 2011
Highlights and features
  • Woman-owned and operated since 2011
  • Custom designs crafted with artistic expertise
  • Handmade desserts using premium ingredients daily
  • Local delivery available in Columbus and Central Ohio
  • Budget-friendly options for every occasion
Services
Custom Cakes
Fate Cakes specializes in fully customized cakes for weddings, birthdays, and events. Our designs range from elegant fondant creations to intricate 3D sculptures. Each cake is crafted with two layers of premium cake and buttercream icing, with options for custom flavors, fillings, and decorations. Pricing starts at $29.50 for a 4" single-tier cake and increases based on size and complexity, with tiered and carved designs available for larger events.
Cupcakes
We offer a variety of standard and themed cupcakes, including vanilla, chocolate, funfetti, and seasonal flavors. Options include custom-colored rosettes, gender reveal designs, and birthday-themed decorations. Cupcakes are available by the dozen starting at $36.00, with individual flavors like buckeye and oreo priced at $3.00 each. Pre-orders are recommended for specialty designs.
Delivery Services
Fate Cakes provides local delivery in Columbus, Ohio, and surrounding areas within a 10-mile radius. Same-day and next-day delivery options are available through DoorDash for individual orders. Tiered cakes and large catering orders are delivered on Saturdays only, with a flat rate based on location. Delivery windows are scheduled between 2:30 PM and 5:00 PM.
Cake Tasting Boxes
Our cake tasting boxes allow clients to sample cake and icing flavors before placing an order. Boxes are available for pickup every Saturday from 12:00 PM to 1:30 PM and include a selection of popular flavors. The tasting box costs $15.00 and serves two people, with customization options for dietary restrictions noted during checkout.
Catering Services
Fate Cakes offers catering for weddings, baby showers, graduations, and corporate events. Services include custom cake towers, dessert tables, and bulk orders of cupcakes or cookies. We provide setup and delivery within Columbus, with options for themed desserts and dietary accommodations. Pricing is tailored to event size and design complexity, with a two-week minimum notice required for custom orders.
People
Marie Johns
Owner
Marie Johns founded Fate Cakes in 2011 after a corporate career, combining her art background with a passion for baking. She personally oversees all designs and operations as a one-woman show, prioritizing quality, creativity, and community engagement in every custom order.
Questions
Do you offer custom cake designs?
Yes, we create custom cakes for weddings, birthdays, and events. Designs include fondant decorations, 3D sculptures, and themed elements.
Are there delivery options?
Local delivery is available in Columbus and Central Ohio through DoorDash for individual orders and Saturday deliveries for tiered cakes.
What are your working hours?
We are open Wednesday 9AM-2PM, Thursday-Friday 9AM-5PM, and Saturday 9AM-2PM. Closed Sunday-Tuesday.
Can I schedule a cake tasting?
Yes, cake tasting boxes are available for pickup every Saturday from 12:00 PM to 1:30 PM for $15.00.
Do you cater to special dietary needs?
We accommodate allergies and dietary restrictions with advance notice. Options include gluten-free treats and flavor substitutions.