Business Details
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Cambridge, Ohio
Established in 1900, Shafer Insurance Agency has served Ohio families and businesses for over a century. Our fourth-generation family-owned agency specializes in personalized insurance solutions, including auto, home, business, life, and farm coverage. As independent agents, we partner with multiple carriers to offer competitive rates and tailored policies. Our experienced team prioritizes client needs, combining deep industry knowledge with a commitment to exceptional service. With decades of collective experience, we deliver comprehensive protection and peace of mind to policyholders across Ohio. 
Services
Auto Insurance
Home Insurance
Business Insurance
Life Insurance
Farm Insurance
Renters Insurance
Boat Insurance
RV/Camper Insurance
ATV Insurance
Jewelry Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1900
Highlights and features
- We offer 125 years of insurance expertise serving Ohio families and businesses
- Our fourth-generation family ownership ensures personalized, client-first service
- As independent agents, we provide multiple carrier options for competitive pricing
- Experienced team with decades of combined industry knowledge and licensing
- We maintain a legacy of tailored insurance solutions since 1900
Services
Auto Insurance
Our auto insurance protects personal and commercial vehicles with comprehensive coverage options. Policies include collision, liability, road assistance, and gap coverage tailored to individual needs. With decades of experience, we help clients find affordable rates while ensuring adequate protection for their automotive investments.
Home Insurance
We provide homeowners, condo owners, and renters with comprehensive property coverage. Policies protect against damage to structures, personal belongings, and liability claims. Our agents help clients customize coverage amounts to match their specific assets and risk exposure.
Business Insurance
Our commercial insurance solutions protect businesses of all sizes with property, liability, and auto coverage. We create customized packages for restaurants, dealerships, and other commercial operations. Policies include bond options and risk management strategies tailored to specific industries.
Life Insurance
We offer life insurance policies to ensure financial security for dependents. Options include term and permanent coverage to meet various needs. Our agents help clients determine appropriate coverage amounts based on family circumstances and financial obligations.
Farm Insurance
Our farm insurance protects agricultural operations with specialized policies for hobby farms and commercial agriculture. Coverage includes equipment, livestock, and crop protection through partnerships with top-rated agribusiness carriers. We help farmers manage risks associated with their specific operations.
People
Mindy Eltringham
Owner / Senior Agent
With 29 years of experience, Mindy has led the agency since 2020. She specializes in personal and commercial insurance lines, maintaining the Shafer family's legacy of client-focused service since 1900.
Shannon Shiflett
Agent
Licensed agent with 7 years of experience, Shannon serves clients from her office in Cambridge. She specializes in matching individuals with appropriate coverage solutions tailored to their specific needs.
Jacilyn Cox
Agent
Jacilyn has provided insurance services for 13 years, holding multiple licenses in property/casualty and life/health insurance. She serves as a notary public while assisting clients with coverage needs.
Laura Walker
Agent
Newly licensed agent Laura brings fresh perspective to the team. With experience in Caldwell and Cambridge areas, she focuses on understanding client needs to recommend appropriate insurance solutions.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We offer auto, home, business, life, farm, renters, boat, RV/camper, ATV, jewelry, and personal umbrella coverage, along with commercial property, liability, and bond options.
Are you a local insurance agency?
Yes, we've served Cambridge, Ohio since 1900 and maintain deep community ties through four generations of family ownership.
Do you offer business insurance solutions?
We provide commercial insurance packages including property, liability, and auto coverage tailored to businesses from small operations to large commercial accounts.
Can you help with life insurance planning?
Our agents assist with determining appropriate life insurance coverage based on family needs, financial obligations, and long-term planning goals.
How does being an independent agency benefit me?
As independent agents, we represent multiple carriers to offer competitive pricing and customized coverage options that match your specific requirements.
