Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Your Trusted Bakery in East Hampton, NY
At Carissa's Bakery, our journey began with the simple act of baking bread and has since grown into a beloved community hub rooted in local values. We operate as a counter-service, all-day bakery specializing in European-style breads, viennoiserie, and vibrant cakes inspired by the surrounding natural beauty, all crafted daily in our modern, sunlit space. Our culinary philosophy centers on wholesome, seasonal ingredients sourced thoughtfully from nearby growers and producers who prioritize organic farming, sustainability, and transparency. We are committed to responsible practices, minimizing waste and plastic use while delivering delicious, healthful products. Recognized for excellence, we received the 2020 James Beard Foundation Outstanding Restaurant Design Award and were named a 2025 James Beard Foundation Outstanding Bakery Semi-Finalist.

Our team of dedicated professionals brings expertise in pastry, kitchen operations, and hospitality to create a seamless experience for our guests. With multiple locations across East Hampton and Sag Harbor, we offer both dine-in and takeout options, including pre-order services for picnics, events, and special occasions. Our partnerships with local businesses, such as KITH Treats, further reflect our commitment to community collaboration. Through years of refining our craft, we have established ourselves as a trusted destination for high-quality baked goods and a model for sustainable practices in the bakery industry.
Services
Bread Baking Pastry Creation Catering Services Coffee Bar Pantry Items
Highlights and features
  • We offer European-style breads and pastries baked daily using locally sourced ingredients
  • Our team includes award-winning pastry chefs and experienced hospitality professionals
  • We prioritize sustainable practices with minimal waste and plastic usage
  • Multiple convenient locations with flexible ordering options available
  • Recognized by the James Beard Foundation for restaurant design excellence
Services
European-Style Breads
Our European-style breads are baked daily using traditional techniques and sustainably sourced flour. Each loaf showcases regional recipes with modern interpretations, from crusty baguettes to hearty sourdoughs. We prioritize local grain partnerships to ensure freshness and support regional agriculture while maintaining authentic baking methods passed down through generations.
Viennoiserie Pastries
Handcrafted viennoiserie includes buttery croissants, pain au chocolat, and seasonal fruit danishes made with imported French butter. Our pastry chefs employ multi-day lamination processes to achieve perfect flakiness while incorporating local produce for fillings and garnishes. Each batch is prepared fresh daily to maintain optimal texture and flavor.
Pre-Order Catering
Custom catering services for picnics, beach days, and special dinners with 48-hour advance notice. Clients can select from curated menus featuring signature baked goods, sandwiches, and seasonal specialties. Orders can be placed up to 60 days in advance with specified pickup times for convenience.
Coffee Bar
Full coffee bar offering espresso drinks, pour-over coffee, and specialty beverages using beans from ethical roasters. Our baristas receive ongoing training in latte art and brewing techniques to ensure consistent quality. The menu includes plant-based milk alternatives and seasonal drink specials that complement our baked goods.
Pantry Items
Curated selection of pantry staples including house-made jams, preserves, and baking mixes. Products feature seasonal ingredients sourced from local farms and producers who follow organic practices. These ready-to-use items allow customers to recreate our signature flavors at home with minimal preparation.
People
Lori Chemla
Co-Founder + Managing Partner
Lori Chemla co-founded Carissa's Bakery with a vision to create a community-focused bakery that combines exceptional baked goods with sustainable practices. With extensive hospitality experience, she oversees operations and strategic growth while maintaining the bakery's commitment to quality and local partnerships.
Carissa Waechter
Co-Founder + Pastry Chef + Baker
As co-founder and head pastry chef, Carissa Waechter brings decades of baking expertise to our kitchen. Her innovative approach to traditional techniques earned the bakery James Beard recognition. She personally develops recipes that balance classic methods with modern interpretations using seasonal ingredients.
Renie Costello
Head of Operations and Human Resources
Renie Costello manages daily operations and human resources, ensuring smooth bakery functions across all locations. With a background in hospitality management, she implements efficient systems while maintaining the bakery's employee-centric culture and commitment to professional development.
Laura Lopez
Kitchen Manager
Laura Lopez leads kitchen operations with expertise in coordinating production across multiple locations. She maintains quality control standards while managing inventory and staff scheduling. Her leadership ensures consistent product quality and timely service during peak hours.
Arina Churbanova
Pastry Chef
Arina Churbanova serves as our dedicated pastry chef, executing complex viennoiserie and dessert items with precision. She trained in classical pastry arts and brings technical expertise to our bakery's daily operations, maintaining high standards for texture and presentation in every pastry.
Questions
What are your current operating hours?
We operate Thursday through Monday from 8:30am to 4pm at most locations, with slight variations at our Newtown Lane location which closes at 3:30pm on weekends.
Do you offer catering services for special events?
Yes, we provide pre-order catering services with 48-hour notice for picnics, beach outings, and special dinners. Custom orders can be placed up to 60 days in advance.
Are pets allowed at your locations?
Well-behaved dogs are welcome in the garden area of our Pantigo Road location, but must remain on a leash. Misbehaving pets will be asked to leave.
What sustainability practices do you implement?
We minimize waste and plastic use through composting programs, reusable packaging, and partnerships with local organic producers who follow sustainable farming practices and fair trade principles.
Do you have any award-winning products or recognitions?
We received the 2020 James Beard Foundation Outstanding Restaurant Design Award and were named a 2025 James Beard Foundation Outstanding Bakery Semi-Finalist for our culinary excellence.
Can I place online orders for pickup?
Yes, online pre-ordering is available at our Sag Harbor and Pantigo locations for convenient pickup. Simply select your date and preferred pickup time during checkout.