Lake Street Cafe

Welcome to Lake Street Cafe, a restaurant where we pride ourselves on providing a fun, friendly atmosphere with an upscale feel. Our philosophy is simple - we believe in going back to the basics. We make everything from scratch using only the freshest ingredients, bake our own breads and desserts, and make all of our stocks. Our commitment to great food and friendly, professional service sets us apart from the rest.

Our dining rooms are uniquely different, offering two distinct experiences. The casual side is bright and colorful, while the Main Dining Room is quaint and intimate, with white linens and candles adding to the ambiance. Our menus are presented in the front cover of old hardcover books, a touch that has been known to spark conversation at the table. Our waitstaff use children's books for their specials and general information, adding a playful touch to the dining experience.

Our Services

At Lake Street Cafe, we offer a variety of services designed to enhance your dining experience. Our menu features a range of delicious dishes, from appetizers to desserts, all made with the freshest ingredients. We also offer a comprehensive wine list, recognized by the Wine Spectator Award of Excellence from 2003 to the present. With over 500 selections, including vintages ranging from 1963 to 2020, we have something for every palate. Our wine cellar is kept at 64 F, ensuring that each bottle is stored to perfection. We also offer a selection of verticals from 12 different wineries, ranging from 4 bottles to a 14-bottle vertical.

Our menu includes a range of options, from wood-fired pizzas to gourmet entrees. Our lunch menu features fresh, seasonal ingredients, while our dinner menu offers a more extensive selection of dishes. We cater to both casual diners and those looking for a more upscale dining experience.

Our Atmosphere

At Lake Street Cafe, we strive to create an atmosphere that is both welcoming and sophisticated. Whether you're visiting for a quick lunch or a special occasion dinner, we aim to provide a comfortable and enjoyable dining experience. Our friendly, professional staff is dedicated to ensuring that every guest feels valued and appreciated.

We believe that dining should be an experience, not just a meal. That's why we've created a space that is not only delicious but also beautiful and inviting. From the colorful decor in our casual dining area to the intimate ambiance of our Main Dining Room, we've designed every detail to make you feel at home.

Our Commitment to Quality

At Lake Street Cafe, we are committed to providing the highest quality food and service. We believe in using only the freshest ingredients, sourced locally whenever possible, to create dishes that are both delicious and nutritious. Our chefs are dedicated to preparing each meal with care and attention, ensuring that every dish that leaves our kitchen meets our high standards.

We also believe in providing exceptional service. Our staff is trained to be friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable about our menu and wine list. We strive to make every guest feel welcome and valued, and we're always happy to accommodate special requests or dietary needs.

Our History

Lake Street Cafe has been a staple in the Elkhart Lake community for over two decades. Since opening our doors, we've been dedicated to providing a unique dining experience that sets us apart from the rest. We've built a reputation for great food, friendly service, and an extensive wine list, earning us recognition from the Wine Spectator Award of Excellence.

Over the years, we've continually updated our menu and services to meet the changing needs of our guests. We've added new dishes, expanded our wine list, and even introduced new dining areas to accommodate different preferences. Through it all, we've remained committed to our core values: quality, service, and community.

Our Community

At Lake Street Cafe, we believe in being an active and supportive member of our community. We source ingredients from local farmers and suppliers whenever possible, helping to boost the local economy and ensure that our dishes are made with the freshest ingredients. We also participate in local events and charities, giving back to the community that has supported us over the years.

We're proud to be a part of the vibrant Elkhart Lake community, and we look forward to continuing to serve our guests for many years to come. Whether you're a local resident or just visiting for a day, we invite you to join us at Lake Street Cafe for a dining experience you won't forget.